102 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The composition is too heavy on the right, cropping it closer to the post on the left would have helped the balance.

(5 years and 884 days ago)

Street life
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Nice golden ball!

(5 years and 891 days ago)

Le Ballon d
avatar Wayne Cheah

Great! Without this explanation, who knows what "Athanaric" means or is?

(5 years and 892 days ago)

Athanaric
avatar Rumi
Rumi says:

is that a crowd effect, very nicely done I like the texture on the ball gl. author

(5 years and 894 days ago)

Le Ballon d
avatar EmiK
EmiK says:

I like how you can see the cables running from house to house ~ looks like =)

(5 years and 900 days ago)

Sunset over the city
avatar wazowski
wazowski says:

! Good luck!

(5 years and 902 days ago)

Wazobot
no avatar

very nice!! i gave you 100% simply because its nice and also because i was waiting for the 1st person not to do flowers! nice work.

(5 years and 902 days ago)

Sunset over the city
no avatar

Beautiful. I really like the silhouettes.

(5 years and 905 days ago)

Sunset over the city
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

Your Wellcome!

(5 years and 907 days ago)

Vlad Tepesh
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

Very Nice ! Congrats

(5 years and 908 days ago)

Vlad Tepesh
avatar alyssadanielle

Congratulations on your first place! Wonderful entry!!!

(5 years and 912 days ago)

Vlad Tepesh
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

Congrats for your first place!

(5 years and 912 days ago)

Vlad Tepesh
avatar kyricom
kyricom says:

Pretty good. Looks like him (Dracula = son of Dracul = son of the devil - his dad wasn't too nice of a guy either)

(5 years and 915 days ago)

Vlad Tepesh
avatar theodosiou

Dracula?

(5 years and 915 days ago)

Vlad Tepesh
avatar Glockman
Glockman says:

not bad. gl

(5 years and 920 days ago)

Wireless
avatar spaceranger

Nice drawing though a bit murky in tone due to the photo, if you have Photoshop you are allowed to adjust brightness on your entries which would improve the look, as long as you show the original image in your SBS. Even so I see good skills in this.

(5 years and 922 days ago)

Wireless
avatar lincemiope

fine colours..fine photo

(5 years and 928 days ago)

The Look Reloaded
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Very beautiful! But I think it wasn't wireless those times...

(5 years and 928 days ago)

Wireless
avatar friiskiwi
friiskiwi says:

looks so much better

(5 years and 929 days ago)

The Look Reloaded
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

Congrats

(5 years and 1096 days ago)

S.J. in the Wilderness
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

When I first saw this image come up, I thought it was a photo. VERY WELL DONE! The only giveaway was that the pepperoni looks to be "floating" slightly above the pizza, and is too pink and "raw" looking, with too even an overall color - Once cooked, they are a bit browner around the edges, and the melted cheese slightly overlaps the edges in places...

Still, this is an exceptional render. High mark from me.

(5 years and 1096 days ago)

Pizza Avgvsta
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 1100 days ago)

S.J. in the Wilderness
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

Nice Congrats

(5 years and 1101 days ago)

Tray full
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

It really look old author! LOL, look at it, nicely done and best of luck!

(5 years and 1102 days ago)

Old Jack o
avatar George55
George55 says:

Looks real nice. Takes time to draw something like this, but at the end, you should be happy with the results. Good luck!

(5 years and 1102 days ago)

S.J. in the Wilderness
avatar lchappell
lchappell says:

looking pretty good

(5 years and 1106 days ago)

S.J. in the Wilderness
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

Very nice author! Well done! I love it!

(5 years and 1107 days ago)

S.J. in the Wilderness
avatar Drivenslush

great job author .. this image still brings tears to my eyes.. good luck

(5 years and 1109 days ago)

S.J. in the Wilderness
no avatar

I see your stil life got the better of you and you had to have a bite, art is a hungry job.

I like your choice of image, I agree that you have done a wonderful job with the tray handles

Over all i really like your image author , well done.

(5 years and 1110 days ago)

Tray full
avatar Chuck
Chuck says:

Nice Congrats

(5 years and 1110 days ago)

My castle
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The mouth is wonky for the camera angle. The top looks flat, while the bottom shows depth, which is opposite the depth carved into the eye. Also, the wall being the exact same shade of orange as the pumpkins, which are all exactly the same color, is a bit flat and unrealistic looking. Great concept, though!

(5 years and 1112 days ago)

Old Jack o
avatar Glockman
Glockman says:

congrats on 3rd.

(5 years and 1114 days ago)

My castle
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

I like the one with the bite out of it! Nice job with the shading values of the tray handles. The treats could use a little more depth with values, they look a bit flat, but a nice image anyway.

(5 years and 1114 days ago)

Tray full
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 1115 days ago)

My castle
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Very nice concept for this design, love the textures and images you used.

(5 years and 1115 days ago)

Our ancestors
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Wonderful texturing, from the subtle, yet readable "Welcome" and the mat ridges, to the very fine wall texture. Really well done!

(5 years and 1120 days ago)

Breaking and entry
avatar dlanswayne

Nice modeling.Luv it

(5 years and 1130 days ago)

Alien lovestory
avatar 6tann
6tann says:

it will be good if we have Hi-res...... good concept but dont have good detail...... good luck author.....

(5 years and 1131 days ago)

Alien lovestory
avatar dilsedosty

nice entry........... all the best

(5 years and 1131 days ago)

Alien lovestory
avatar jamespaul
jamespaul says:

congratulations athanaric
well deserved win n really fab work

(5 years and 1135 days ago)

Thallasomedon
avatar Geexman
Geexman says:

In the words of mossy B "its too dark"..... I can see the effect you`re going for author .. just a little tweaking needed dont be afraid to ask for help

(5 years and 1145 days ago)

Spark in the dark
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Looks much better with a bit of reflection on the hound's head. Good job!

(5 years and 1147 days ago)

Goth walking stick
avatar Bitmap
Bitmap says:

first of all you should add an SBS for the entry
great effort with this one but I suggest to add an HDRI map for the reflection and replace the black bgackground , and finally I suggest that you focus on one of the sticks and add a blur effect (depth of field DOF) for the other one ....
GL Author ...

(5 years and 1148 days ago)

Goth walking stick
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The hound head is a bit too matte and flat finished, but the stick itself if beautifully textured and colored! You should make the hound head less gray, matching it more to the stick.

(5 years and 1151 days ago)

Goth walking stick
avatar bcabilan
bcabilan says:

Welcome to the site author. For your entry, even how simple it is, you should have added at least a written step-by-step (SBS) showing how you made the entry in the description to follow with the rules. Good luck to you. Hope to seing some of your work soon.

(5 years and 1151 days ago)

Spark in the dark