Firstly, interesting treatment. I like it. Maybe I'm being picky but shouldn't the dragons reflect on the black surface the same was the symbol does? Also - at least looking at it on my monitors - there are some grey artefacts on the black surface that shouldn't be there.
No, no, My advice was not on editing or not the picture. I mentionned that because I was not sure if it was permitted or not. If you say it's permitted, I believe you.
My advice to you was to take care because in the contest goal, it is asked to "Create two photos", and here you have twice the same picture (edited or not, they are the same) ... Just take a look to the other entries.
advice is always welcome, but the advice given here is not factual, it is based on your understanding of the brief and rules,you need to read the pxleyes faq's as to what is and what is not permitted in editing and if necessary we need a moderator to come along and put this to bed.
(2 days 3 hr ago)
entry removed...
author says:
it is my belief that a global edit is allowed in pxleyes, what is not allowed is spot editing.
Yes, it can be the same subject ... But here, more than the same subject, it's exactly the same picture, you just applied a negative effect in post-treatment (I even don't think if it's permited to do such manipulation in PXLEyes photo-contests ... ).
No worries
(1 day 8 hr ago)
That's what I thought too, they are very small.
(1 day 8 hr ago)
Thanks
(1 day 8 hr ago)
Thank you! I will replace than a photo!
(1 day 8 hr ago)
wow... that looks like quite a banquet ( or else the average snack for three teenagers)
(1 day 9 hr ago)
mmmmmmmmmm... I LOVE Caramellos
(1 day 9 hr ago)
Good use of negative space
(1 day 17 hr ago)
With a better focus it might have been a nice pic.
(1 day 17 hr ago)
Great ! Feels like the light is falling down !
(1 day 17 hr ago)
I m finished !! LOL !!
(1 day 18 hr ago)
Thank you for the compliment pingenvy.
(1 day 19 hr ago)
I think this is pretty cool! Imaginative......
(1 day 19 hr ago)
I stand corrected. Always liked the image.
(1 day 19 hr ago)
Nice choice for black white. Subtle image. Nice.
(1 day 19 hr ago)
Glad you liked it Remsphoto !
(1 day 20 hr ago)
I have no idea about country music, but this is a great photo!
(1 day 20 hr ago)
The sill is the subject and should be the focus.
(1 day 21 hr ago)
Well... from my point of view - that would be good. Reminds me of high school.
(1 day 21 hr ago)
You better stop before it gets too juicy
(1 day 21 hr ago)
Yes?
(1 day 21 hr ago)
Yes. When I said "old photos", I meant my old photos.
(1 day 21 hr ago)
Thanks Mark! Dunno if a 70's shirt is good or bad LOL
(1 day 21 hr ago)
My footware of choice. These are at least 12 yrs old.
(1 day 21 hr ago)
Very nice. Looks like a 70's t-shirt.
(1 day 21 hr ago)
Thanks for pointing out the grey areas, I had to get a real weird angle on my screen to see them but they are gone now.
(1 day 22 hr ago)
"This is Major Tom to Ground Control...I'm stepping through the door and I'm floating in a most peculiar way....."

(1 day 22 hr ago)
Firstly, interesting treatment. I like it. Maybe I'm being picky but shouldn't the dragons reflect on the black surface the same was the symbol does? Also - at least looking at it on my monitors - there are some grey artefacts on the black surface that shouldn't be there.
(2 days ago)
Okey. My mistake.
(2 days ago)
You still have time to edit, there's also a dark line just below the pendant that shouldn't be there
(2 days ago)
I've edited it. Hope this one fits better
(2 days ago)
enough said already
(2 days ago)
entry removed...
Like the theme here
(2 days ago)
Like the way both images are framed -- nice composition
(2 days 1 hr ago)
WOW! Stupid exclamation, but it serves well its purpose. Nice work, author
(2 days 1 hr ago)
Thank you
(2 days 1 hr ago)
Thank you!
(2 days 2 hr ago)
Sill is visible and evening light is on the fence...
'Take a photograph of a windowsill from the inside looking out. The goal is to capture the morning or evening light in your image.'
Maybe I don't understand something thereat...
(2 days 2 hr ago)
Lookin like that, someone might wanna give her a good peeling !!
(2 days 2 hr ago)
Excellent Diptych. It's great you succeed in replacing exctly at the same place twice ! Theme is perfectly followed and the picture is great ! Bravo !
(2 days 2 hr ago)
No, no, My advice was not on editing or not the picture. I mentionned that because I was not sure if it was permitted or not. If you say it's permitted, I believe you.
My advice to you was to take care because in the contest goal, it is asked to "Create two photos", and here you have twice the same picture (edited or not, they are the same) ... Just take a look to the other entries.
(2 days 2 hr ago)
entry removed...
Is it the same picture cut ?
(2 days 2 hr ago)
friiskiwi - Thank you. I am glad you like it.
(2 days 2 hr ago)
advice is always welcome, but the advice given here is not factual, it is based on your understanding of the brief and rules,you need to read the pxleyes faq's as to what is and what is not permitted in editing and if necessary we need a moderator to come along and put this to bed.
(2 days 3 hr ago)
entry removed...
it is my belief that a global edit is allowed in pxleyes, what is not allowed is spot editing.
(2 days 3 hr ago)
entry removed...
You know author, I don't care which picture you upload, I was just saying that to you as an advice before Moderators remove your entry.
(2 days 4 hr ago)
entry removed...
Yes, it can be the same subject ... But here, more than the same subject, it's exactly the same picture, you just applied a negative effect in post-treatment (I even don't think if it's permited to do such manipulation in PXLEyes photo-contests ... ).
(2 days 4 hr ago)
entry removed...
Fantastic
(2 days 5 hr ago)
Nowhere in the brief does it say that the two photos cannot be the same subject !
(2 days 5 hr ago)
entry removed...
Most of them do, kyri. This one looks like a painting. Well done, author
(2 days 5 hr ago)
They look like light fixtures. Interesting
(2 days 5 hr ago)