Congrats George55!

This is a very sweet image, author, shows a lot of depth, and work on the flowers and stems.

Not to say this isn't a good entry, CBR isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Bob is talking about CBR short for Chopped Beyond Recognition. It's a term used when a source contest entry is so far altered that you can't really see the image any longer. It usually implies that the entry could have been made with most any other source for the same or very similar result. While the image created may be very nice it doesn't show a dependency on the original contest source which is the intention of having a contest source in the first place.
I will say that this is a very nice entry and there are others that are CBR and also very nice works just not very source dependent.

Amazing!!!

Nice CBR.

Well done, a lot of work went in to this = )

dat's a lotta fun

a push-me-pull-me

cute little dumpling!

Looks so realistic, very good job author.

wow... levelly creation!

very very very feel made author, nice creativity on it.

Wow! I didn't recognise this as the dandelion. Love to see something transformed into something completely different. Beautifully done.

Ah, love this especially. I did this as a child, caught a caterpillar in a little jar, watched it make its cocoon, then eventually turn into a moth - fascinating! Good job with this source.

very pretty

Very nice image, author, and I think the lighting/shadows work fine.

Looks good, except for the shadow that falls on the main rock and on the monk.

Congrats into making it to reserve 1 in the next round.

Simple but so beautiful!

I loved!

That's really simple and clever and very realistic looking. Well done

Great work.........Good Luck Author.

I felt like this scene is about the steampunks airship wars.

I'm sorry if I'm too late to comment and give you my thoughts, author. When I'm looking to all the way down to the city, it's just a modern city. Steampunks should be on the city where the steams, steamclouds, pipes, post-apocalyptic scene, junkyards and all the old-style elements scattered around. I have one good resource for the scene; type 'machinarium' on any search engines. It will leads you to an animated webpage which tells the stories of tiny little robot with the environment of steampunks (junkyards).

Anyway, it's a great entry to come across. Steampunks entries (in my mind) will be crowded with people, costumes, bots, etc. But you MADE ANOTHER style, playing with scene and that's the way I like it.

Good luck, author. Cheers for the best!

I love it!!!

Super High Marks and Fav!..Amazing work!! GL author.

Superb entry author GL

Fantastic scene made.... goes my fav..

beautiful work author!!

Indeed better. GL author!

Good image, author. Nice source finds. IMO the hull on the source ship at right is wonky...no fault of yours, but if you had moved it to the right and had the border cut off the jagged part of the hull as if it was emerging from our right, the broken hull wouldn't be a distraction. (As it certainly is for me right now).

This has a beautiful feel to it. Nice work, author. The only thing that distracts me is that the moon is in the background, yet there is a light source causing the brightness on the front of the tree and the woman. This could be electronic light, but judging from the feel of the shot...it wouldn't be artificial light. Don't mean to be too nitpicky...I love the image...just the analytical side of me is getting the better of me. Nice work, author.

Nice light...........good luck

oh.... so mystical..... gud luck friend

I thought this will make to the next round............

Perfection is the word that really fits here.

Gread mystery mood, I like it a lot! Good luck, author!

fantastic lighting....... good luck

Great job, author!

Beautifully done.

Very nice job, author, without external sources! Good luck!

Good luck on the next round!

Congrats with a spot in the next round

I WANNA VOTE FOR THIS PIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! It is fantastico!

Cool!

Your mistake ... I wear glasses too (for now only for myopia). But when I'm at my PC, I take them off - I can't read using them...

I'd like to be in a place like that in this moment... it's relaxing!

nice 1

good work Author..

Very nice! Love the elephants....they fit right in!