Gone but Not Forgoten - created by Chuck


Gone but Not Forgoten
Favs: 0SBS: 14Hi-resRank: 12/16Score: 51.4% (0)6668 views

Spec Thanks to Thorinsise for use of this picture found on Flickr Photo Sharing and on thornisise photo stream.

(5 years and 3306 days ago)

1 Source:

avatar ponti55
ponti55 says:

place shadows under each cross, and try adjusting the brightness, the original source was a bit too bright.

avatar cabldawg71

Yes I agree too bright and a little shadow at the bottom of the crosses will help greatly. Also you could push the shorter grass onto the crosses just a bit to make it not float. Very easy fix for higher votes Good luck Author

author says:

Hay Thanks guys Thanks. How's this any better?

avatar sunzet
sunzet says:

I think you should dim or fade the bluish background, maybe even som slight blur also.

avatar cabldawg71

better

author says:

Hey Thanks I darkened the blue a little more and added some blur to the blue what do you think?..if you look in sbs. the original flickr picture their day & night

avatar DanLundberg

This is a difficult background to work with. The view is looking down towards the lower far field with the foreground sloping away. However, you treated the foreground as flat [my eyes interpret the crosses as equal-sized and vertically true], but that's inconsistent with being able to see the tops of the hay bales in the far field. The light is from the upper left corner, so we should be looking at the shadowed side of the crosses and they should have long, strong shadows going south-southeast (like those of the hay bales). If the crosses are marking graves, they seem too close together. And then they don't seem to be organized in a cemetary-like grid (after adjusting for perspective, of course).

avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Crosses need some shadows...

avatar ricky777
ricky777 says:

lightings and shadows doesn't feel right. sky is too blue and dark and w/o any evidence where the light is coming from to cast such a strong shadow on the stones. like the others were saying, celtic crosses needed dark shadows too to match the stones'.

author says:

Ok Thanks I Here's a remake any better?

avatar DanLundberg

Better. The shadows need to be darker for more consistency with those in the background, need to be thicker (same width as the cross elements casting the shadow), and need to be skewed so the cross-piece's shadow is parallel to the cross piece. I still think having the top of each row noticeably lower than the top of the row in front of it would capture the falling away of the foreground for better linkage with the background.

author says:

Thanks for comments I have made some adjustments and added to sbs.

avatar sunzet
sunzet says:

Much better, but you still need some work with the shadows. Blur them a bit with gaussian blur (not to much though) and then also maybe 80% opacity on them. I´d also think you should change the perspective, so that the shadows "leans" on the ground, I´m not sure how to explain that better, but if you look at a cemeteryphoto you might see how I mean. GL

avatar pingenvy
pingenvy says:

I like the image, but the cross bars on the shadows need to run parallel ot the horizon just like the striations on the ground to make visual sense.

avatar sunzet
sunzet says:

There you go!

avatar hereisanoop

fine work

Howdie stranger!
If you want to rate this picture or participate in this contest, just:

LOGIN HERE or REGISTER FOR FREE


Celtic Cross Photoshop Contest


Watcher
Watcher
by
ponti55
14105 views
- final score: 62.2%

Cave of the Forgotten Souls
CaveoftheForgottenSouls
by
ponti55
13205 views
- final score: 59.2%

celtics rock
celticsrock
by
gornats
13788 views
- final score: 59%

CBR
CBR
by
nasirkhan
11541 views
- final score: 57.4%

Another Place in Time
AnotherPlaceinTime
by
westfall
13032 views
- final score: 55.6%

n/a
na
by
madelinerayne
4203 views
- final score: 55.6%

preeeetty....
preeeetty
by
gornats
3029 views
- final score: 55.5%

Celtic Ascent to heaven
CelticAscenttoheaven
by
xwd
6910 views
- final score: 55%

Peace Dude!
PeaceDude
by
Drivenslush
5161 views
- final score: 53.1%

relaaaaaax
relaaaaaax
by
MrHack
2893 views
- final score: 52.5%

Summer Time Bug
SummerTimeBug
by
xwd
5119 views
- final score: 51.6%

Gone but Not Forgoten
GonebutNotForgoten
by
Chuck
6669 views
- final score: 51.4%

THE BLOB
THEBLOB
by
jpsmsu40
9207 views
- final score: 51.4%

Spring Time
SpringTime
by
Chuck
4010 views
- final score: 50.4%

Nature
Nature
by
solaf
6011 views
- final score: 47.6%

Water Cross
WaterCross
by
Alan2641
5590 views
- final score: 47.2%

Howdie Guest!
You need to be logged in to rate this entry and participate in the contests!

LOGIN HERE or REGISTER FOR FREE