Reflection needs to start underneath the lighter, fire alarm isn't straight... Reply »

Reply:

Let me see you put something together. This is time consuming. Beside, it's the idea that counts. Reply »

Reply:

I would have to agree with CMYK46. The drop shadow is a bit much to the left and the refection is crooked. Plus the top of the source image is a bit tall. Do you see how the top stick out above the lighter outer casing? The lighter is also at a different angle than the source. Don't get mad, just try and fix it, mmkay? I'll come back and vote later. Reply »

Reply:

Author, without wanting to sound harsh, if you have no interest in improving your skills or receiving constructive feedback, then this is not the place to submit your work! Take on board the feedback these people give you - I'll hold off my vote for now to see if you do Reply »

Reply:

ironic idea, nice Reply »

Reply:

Author: well, yes, the idea does count but it's the execution of the idea and how well you carry it through that will earn you the votes. Please try to be open minded about the criticism........it is meant only to help you. CMYK usually gives rather terse comments but they, as well as all the others, are meant only in a helpful way. Reply »

Reply:

I understand where you guys are coming from. I just found myself getting discouraged, because I entered too many contests at once, and I am suppose to be focusing on my college assignments. Here, I fell behind in my schooling and became frustrated. Sorry. Oh! And I do appreciate the feedback. It has really helped me enhance my skills in other areas of photoshop. Thank you. Reply »

Reply: