not bad

Good effort....

no shadows, and can't see the pipe through the glass, nice though

nice work

Good Job. GL

As you can see in the original source, the shadow under the bread is darker and more defined. Try to put a shadow like that...

thank youu i tried with the darker shadow but my idea was "old picture taken outside"

So, it's a picnic, not table...

Nice try.....

Nice chop, but would score higher if you'd included some stains, tears, creases etc. to give a really authentic aged look, also you've missed out the baguette's shadow, and you would be able to see the pattern of the cloth through the glass

The mood is ok, but I think you'd see some of the cloth through the glasses. Apart from that, you may want to play a bit with the transform tool to change the perspective of the cloth (imo you'd look more from the side to the cloth, according to the glasses' perspective). Good luck!

I agree with the others suggestions but it is still a nice entry. Good Luck!

wonderful idea

A sparkling wine! Very nice! You could upload it in hi res to show us details...

Nice image, well done! GL

the wine should be darker, the glass looks tilted and imo it looks like it's floating.. but good idea

nice idea i really like the bubbles inside the bottle but i think a better background would be welcomed

Nice attempt....

Not bad, but I agree about the background. Up to you if you'd like to change that. Good luck!

nice work

I like it!!!

good idea, but I would probably have made more of a reflection if you chose to keep your background to show that it was a reflective surface. Good Luck!

Maybe some ideas on how to improve this: 1. try to remove the water which is above the bottle, that way it looks like the water is flushing out of it. 2. try to match the color (light) of the bottle with the background. 3. when done take a little bit extra of off the topside of the bottle (there's a white line) 4. when everything is done make a new layer, use a small soft brush (max 5 pxls) and blur the edges of the bottle (make sure you check "Sample All Layers" before you start). That way the hard edges will disappear. Good luck

Interesting idea, the suggestions that rodvdn made could have made a wonderful creation. GL

agrees...