going down the line - created by UncleJimmy


going down the line
Favs: 0SBS: n/aHi-resRank: 45/50Score: 57.8% (0)4270 views

(5 years and 2756 days ago)

avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

It looks like you've over-sharpened this photo, there's a terrible white "halo" effect around the trees. You might be able to correct it somewhat with Image>adjustments>selective color>whites, but you may have to select just the trees and sky, so as not to adjust the rest of the image...

The black of the front most rail car is also a bit too black and over dominates the image, anchoring the eye in that corner.

author says:

Selecting just parts of the photo to adjust would be against the guidelines for photography..."no selective editing" I see what you mean here, but in keeping with photography rules and acting only on the entire image, there is nothing I can do about the minor halo

avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Halos are the one major downside of digital cameras...
Edit: It looks better, now. the halos are not so bright and obvious.

avatar FallingHorse

I think that the image adjustments that Mossy has described are acceptable & within the guidlines - the same methods are used for some 'selective colour' entries in other comps.

avatar robvdn
robvdn says:

@Fallinghorse: the described adjustments by MossyB are not allowed, the fact they are allowed within a 'selective coloring' contest is what 'selective coloring' contests are about and what makes them a special kind of contest.

avatar FallingHorse

The adjustments that Mossy is talking about are not about creating a selective coloured object. It is about adjusting the colour which by the guidlines on the site are allowed as per item 6.5 in the guidlines. The tool says 'selective colour' but it means that you boost(saturate) or desat the colour in the image to correct ie. whites. In fact I can say that there is an entry this week that uses this exact method

What Tools/Alterations Can I use?
In general, you should try to avoid editing your photos, whether in camera or with some editing software on a computer. Being a good photographer also means being able to take good shots without having to edit afterwards. We understand that enhancing pictures after the fact has a long tradition in photography and thus we allow for certain digital darkroom techniques, which is readily available in most photo handling software today. As a general rule, you are allowed to all adjustments which act on the whole picture and on exactly one picture (a.k.a. non selective editing). This includes:

- 6.1.: Level
- 6.2.: Curves
- 6.3.: Hue
- 6.4.: Saturation
****- 6.5.: Color adjustments/shifting****
- 6.6.: Brightness
- 6.7.: Contrast
- 6.8.: Gaussian blur
- 6.9.: Noise reduction
- 6.10.: Sharpness
- 6.11.: Crop and rotate
- 6.12.: Lens correction
- 6.13.: Camera raw editing
- 6.14.: Healing brush to remove dust and scratches from a scan or speckles from dust on your camera's sensor
- 6.15.: Duplicated layers
- 6.16.: Layer blending modes

avatar FallingHorse

Except you can't adjust just the trees or sky as Mossy said - it has to be over the whole image. .... sorry missed that bit lol

Howdie stranger!
If you want to rate this picture or participate in this contest, just:

LOGIN HERE or REGISTER FOR FREE


Leading Lines Photography Contest


The 'Solway Harvester'
TheSolwayHarvester
by
Heathcliffe
10281 views
- final score: 66.8%

Checker Box Lane
CheckerBoxLane
by
riady
10590 views
- final score: 66.7%

The way to home
Thewaytohome
by
patty
10030 views
- final score: 66.3%

Garden
Garden
by
rbrum
8048 views
- final score: 65.3%

Cable railway
Cablerailway
by
patty
9226 views
- final score: 65.2%

Point of Ayre Lighthouse
PointofAyreLighthouse
by
Heathcliffe
6157 views
- final score: 65.1%

That little silhouette
Thatlittlesilhouette
by
maclu2iaf
4681 views
- final score: 64.9%

Venice : S.Marco place
VeniceSMarcoplace
by
annarib
4354 views
- final score: 64.9%

Coming around the Mountain
ComingaroundtheMountain
by
MnMCarta
4319 views
- final score: 64.6%

Towards the green
Towardsthegreen
by
robvdn
4475 views
- final score: 64.6%

Railroad
Railroad
by
rbrum
4905 views
- final score: 64.5%

Over the River
OvertheRiver
by
jeaniblog
3498 views
- final score: 64.4%

Out of Town
OutofTown
by
jeaniblog
3253 views
- final score: 64.2%

Henderson Wave
HendersonWave
by
friiskiwi
3463 views
- final score: 64.2%

Fan Tan Ally
FanTanAlly
by
Pat
6309 views
- final score: 63.7%

City Circle Tram
CityCircleTram
by
riady
6268 views
- final score: 63.5%

Normandy Bridge
NormandyBridge
by
annarib
3566 views
- final score: 63.5%

The 5:30
The530
by
UncleJimmy
3076 views
- final score: 63.1%

Old Passage
OldPassage
by
bandit69
3718 views
- final score: 63%

Under the Bridge
UndertheBridge
by
jeaniblog
4780 views
- final score: 62.7%

All aboard
Allaboard
by
Remsphoto
3594 views
- final score: 62.4%

wave
wave
by
kathyw
3146 views
- final score: 62.4%

Beach 'Groyne'
BeachGroyne
by
Heathcliffe
3961 views
- final score: 62.3%

Simple Sunset
SimpleSunset
by
dem90
3966 views
- final score: 62.2%

Pyramid
Pyramid
by
friiskiwi
5327 views
- final score: 62%

Country Gold
CountryGold
by
adeincyprus
3737 views
- final score: 61.8%

fence
fence
by
kathyw
3053 views
- final score: 61.7%

Yellow brick road
Yellowbrickroad
by
rbrum
6381 views
- final score: 61.4%

Knocking On Heaven's Door
KnockingOnHeavensDoor
by
Iluvscrappy
5187 views
- final score: 61.3%

Look up
Lookup
by
Remsphoto
3160 views
- final score: 61.3%

Up Down Left Right
UpDownLeftRight
by
MnMCarta
3626 views
- final score: 61%

Plantings
Plantings
by
CMYK46
2622 views
- final score: 60.9%

road side
roadside
by
maclu2iaf
3329 views
- final score: 60.8%

To the bridge and beyond
Tothebridgeandbeyond
by
jerostone
3414 views
- final score: 60.6%

Shore to shore
Shoretoshore
by
patty
2693 views
- final score: 60.6%

hilly
hilly
by
maclu2iaf
2834 views
- final score: 60.5%

Church bell tower
Churchbelltower
by
annarib
3309 views
- final score: 60.2%

Aim High
AimHigh
by
friiskiwi
4811 views
- final score: 60.1%

Winter
Winter
by
mazanda
2157 views
- final score: 59.8%

Pier
Pier
by
jbillitteri
2699 views
- final score: 59.1%

Hidden Balcony
HiddenBalcony
by
bandit69
3669 views
- final score: 58.8%

line night market
linenightmarket
by
wooyuenfoo
5765 views
- final score: 58.7%

Bent Grass
BentGrass
by
bandit69
3122 views
- final score: 58.6%

Fishing Pier
FishingPier
by
rbsgrl
3389 views
- final score: 58.3%

going down the line
goingdowntheline
by
UncleJimmy
4271 views
- final score: 57.8%

line building
linebuilding
by
wooyuenfoo
3696 views
- final score: 56.9%

Trough-Fountain
TroughFountain
by
mazanda
2097 views
- final score: 56.6%

King Pelagius
KingPelagius
by
Artifakts
3597 views
- final score: 56.5%

coastline
coastline
by
mazanda
2501 views
- final score: 56.4%

coastline
coastline
by
happyme27
2800 views
- final score: 55.3%

Howdie Guest!
You need to be logged in to rate this entry and participate in the contests!

LOGIN HERE or REGISTER FOR FREE