75 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Very very good work author...extra points for realism...well done

(5 years and 3024 days ago)

E-garbage
avatar Mad
Mad says:

Well-modelled with good texturing and lighting. Conceptually, I love the idea of self-sustaining, garbage-eating bacteria but feel the design of your bin is too basic for that. It looks likes the omnivorous bacteria inside the bin might escape from the place where you throw the trash and spread all over the world!

(5 years and 3025 days ago)

E-garbage
avatar layerstack

Fantastic author!! Great work. Plug sockets in the uk vary in height, as for scale i couldn't comment. All looks great to me

(5 years and 3025 days ago)

E-garbage
avatar secretsather

The floor looks fantastic, as does the trim, but the scale of the Electric plug is way off! Additionally, it should be 13 inches from the floor (to center)

(5 years and 3026 days ago)

E-garbage
avatar greymval
greymval says:

Good idea with the light & dark.

(5 years and 3048 days ago)

Palaekman
avatar secretsather

Very nice! I love different takes on illuminated objects and dynamically lit scenes.

(5 years and 3056 days ago)

Palaekman
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

Congrats for 1st

(5 years and 3149 days ago)

Toothbrush
avatar r1k3r
r1k3r says:

A really good effort. The light from the mr omni's is definitely not bouncing off the mirror. I rarely use Mentalray, preferring Vray. However to solve your problem I would do away with the Omni's. Instead replace them with photometric freelights. These give off real world accurate photons. The problem will also be linked to your mirror material too. The mirror material should be completely black. with the reflectiveness all the way up. This is a neat idea and if the little problem with mirror is sorted will be excellent. Good luck

(5 years and 3151 days ago)

Toothbrush
avatar hsbee
hsbee says:

i hate to be a harsh on it,, but i feel the lighting is a bit off here.. The shadows cast on the surface appears to be very gentle however, the cup looks very dark in the mirror.. Could it be because you did not turn on "secondary bounces" for photons?...

Good modelling and texturing..

(5 years and 3152 days ago)

Toothbrush
no avatar
qwertyzx says:

The table has hard edges. Smooth them to get better result. And the toothbrush should be a bit longer.

(5 years and 3152 days ago)

Toothbrush
avatar victor955
victor955 says:

nice work....keep it up......

(5 years and 3159 days ago)

Pencil
avatar Tuckinator

wow i like it

(5 years and 3171 days ago)

Abstract
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

This is nice but personally I think your image should be brighter. Great job

(5 years and 3173 days ago)

Abstract
avatar madamemonty

Congrats, well done

(5 years and 3177 days ago)

Pencil
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

Congratulations for 1st, great job.

(5 years and 3177 days ago)

Pencil
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Fabulous job author...well done

(5 years and 3177 days ago)

Pencil
avatar Tuckinator

incredible work!

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Pencil
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

Great image, nicely done.

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Pencil
avatar Alan2641
Alan2641 says:

Looks real -- great work

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Pencil
no avatar
kumar says:

good ork

(5 years and 3179 days ago)

Pencil
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

Congrats for your third place, Palaekman!

(5 years and 3190 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

Congrats for 3rd, great job, looks most realistic of all.

(5 years and 3191 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar fasterlizard

its gud but the black spot is creating problem.

(5 years and 3193 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Simply amazing and 110% realistic...well done author

(5 years and 3194 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar IRONCOW
IRONCOW says:

Nice job looks great

(5 years and 3194 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar randy
randy says:

nice texture on the water

(5 years and 3194 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar randy
randy says:

i know its about the water but the concrete could look better or highlight on bump maps

(5 years and 3194 days ago)

Swimming Pool
no avatar
Widiar says:

I was almost blinded by the reflection from the ladders.. very nice and clean work, looks very realistic.

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Swimming Pool
no avatar

nice

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

great job, very real

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar Tuckinator

really cool

(5 years and 3195 days ago)

Swimming Pool
avatar Warlock
Warlock [banned] says:

Congrats well done!

(5 years and 3198 days ago)

Water droplets
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

Congrats for 2nd

(5 years and 3198 days ago)

Water droplets
avatar Tuckinator

nice work here author

(5 years and 3200 days ago)

Water droplets
avatar Tuckinator

hmmmmmm, not bad

(5 years and 3200 days ago)

Kiwi slices
avatar nudanke
nudanke says:

Nice job. A few quick suggestions though.

1) The kiwis look a bit dry. If you have spec on them, it should be increased to make them glossier and give some nice highlights that will sell it as being juicy.

2) The kiwi slice that is resting on the other looks very stiff. Adding a slight bend in the middle would help enhance the realism of this shot.

3) The kiwis don't seem to be casting any sort of shadows. The top slice should be casting a shadow or at the very least there should be some occlusion between it and the bottom slice to help ground it.

Again, very good work! These critiques are only meant as food for thought so I hope you don't take it the wrong way.

(5 years and 3202 days ago)

Kiwi slices
no avatar
Widiar says:

Awesome work. Looks very authentic.Only the juice drops are missing.. Good job here.

(5 years and 3204 days ago)

Kiwi slices
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

Congrats for your second place, Palaekman!

(5 years and 3205 days ago)

Moon base
avatar erathion
erathion says:

very nice...gl

(5 years and 3208 days ago)

Water droplets
avatar Warlock
Warlock [banned] says:

Nice idea, and a good looking end result top job!

(5 years and 3208 days ago)

Water droplets
avatar lchappell
lchappell says:

nice effect

(5 years and 3208 days ago)

Water droplets
no avatar
rizhima says:

great....

(5 years and 3209 days ago)

Moon base
no avatar
Widiar says:

Looks a bit dull, like you just started and then let it go.. you could add some extra buildings and textures (or some sort of rocket/lander/w'ever) to make it a little more interesting. Maybe some huge moon boulders/rocks and shadows for the background too?

(5 years and 3209 days ago)

Moon base
avatar mounirupa
mounirupa says:

congrats for third place....

(5 years and 3216 days ago)

Living room
no avatar

congrats on third place....

(5 years and 3219 days ago)

Living room
avatar JoeCacia
JoeCacia says:

Lovely work

(5 years and 3226 days ago)

Lost diver
avatar erathion
erathion says:

very nice...gl

(5 years and 3228 days ago)

Living room
avatar erathion
erathion says:

very clean chop author...best of luck

(5 years and 3228 days ago)

Bonsai Tree
avatar Lamantine
Lamantine says:

Very good.

(5 years and 3228 days ago)

Lost diver
no avatar
UPGRADE says:

I am now a fan of your work. Good job

(5 years and 3228 days ago)

Living room