fab

Beautiful image...IMO the climber has a highlight on his back that is coming from a light source that isn't there, soften it and blend the trees into the walkway a little more..Make it crisper..Hope this helps and Good Luck =)

Nice idea, I agree with the climber comments, and i think a little subtle use of the 'dodge' tool to give some sharper highlights on the central structure would really make it 'pop'... well done

Congrats!!

The horizon line looks a little bit wavy...

What erikuri says. No problem that you use the liquify tool to make a waterfall, but keep the horizon line straight (or just as it is in the source image). Mood is ok, though perhaps a bit weird to see a moon in front of the clouds. Good luck!

Thank you...is the horizon better?

I know it's a bit complicated, but now it seems like the water direction is up, what it's impossible, 'cause we're talking about a waterfall... If you get the horizon line straight, parallel with the edge of the pic, everything's gonna be NICE - because your work is beautiful!

thanks again...ill try my best at fixing it

doubt the moon can cast such a bright flare, or maybe it's because i've never seen it before -_-

Nice chop, but not very dusky...

It's daylight saving time here Thanks CMYK...

lol@day light savings

Adding color to the end of the sky and maybe darkening it would make it look more like dusk.

Thank you jawshoewhah! Darkened the sky a little... Not much, I'm afraid to lose the moody atmosphere

nice

great job

congrats on your placement.. all entries are winners in such a hard comp...

lovin it!

Try a displacement map & high res version...

nice work!

Would like to see high res version.......but quite nice.

agrees with high res version.

Very nice image...gl

I would have loved to seen the step by step and high res for this image.,It could have helped heaps in the voting.

great