The reflection need more opacity.

ramid; less opacity? .. This is no reflection; only a copy paste underneeth the original

One the other hand there is almost no opacity at all in the original photo, so this might just be a corkscrew photographed on a mirror, and if that´s the case no opacity is needed. But it would though look better and more realistic if the glass and bottle faded away.

sunzet, I believe the original photo (corkscrew) was photographed on a mirror.

Well, there you go then! But...if I can be picky (or just tippy) that would require a different angle of the mirrowed picture - wich is almost impossible to pull off if you don´t have that source as well. I know I wouldn´t anyway. GL

Even on a mirror, if yoy pay attention, there's a little difference between the images (a bit, just a bit of low opacity is welcome...)

Reflection need a lot more work...effect is nice but for the reflecyions need one good gradient layer and a slight changing position of the reflection....good luck

Made some changes according to suggestions. Hope this is better.

It´s more opacity, but the wine in the mirror is darker than the other. There are some more changes that could be done, I just don´t know how explain that in english.

There should be some sort of horizontal plane depicted here, even if just slightly, and the reflections should have a little less value. Still, this is a good idea...

too bad the reflection sucks..