cool idea and good job too

The water looks really fake but it's a really good idea You should put it more transparent.

the water, as well as looking fake, is also too light for the depth it is at!

You could have selected a better source picture for the background.. a picture of a well or something. I like the idea, but a lot of more work needed.

great,gl

Well nice idea and nice use of the source but the water beneath if would have been made sort of a twister then it would have been the best....a superman tag on the fellow would also have added some funny part i guess....

Not bad, blur the wter edges a bit, and use the smudge brush to make them, look like they are actully touching the walls...also try making the water a bit darker and his shadow a tad smaller..GL

so what about it now hope to be good than the first one

yes thats better ..good job