Very good

Great work... GL...

Nice job , good luck.

It's a lot more like a pop up book that a lot of them so good luck

Obviously a lot of effort, and a great result acheived. One of the best. gl

Thanks for the very nice comments. It was quite the challenge. We need more contests like this where you HAVE to try new techniques. Everyone who attempted it should be congratulated!!!

Great result, wondeful

Great work!

Great........job Author. G/L.

very good work.good luck

Congrats for your first place, Artgirl!

Well done, congrats!

congratulations

Congrats

Really I like this one. Maybe you could choose other theme for the pop up, a older theme, like the books, anyway good work.

good work.

Like it

SBS would be nice...

Sbs Added CMYK

perfectly on theme and nicely put together. Well done.

Great entry, and nice to see you back, author

Great job! And for sure a book I would have loved, as I was a child. It looks really convincing and what is especially good, is that you thought about making folds in the different elements. That makes it even more realistic. Good luck and welcome back!

Thanks Great to see some familar faces Lelaina,ponti55,Bob Ps, congrats on the mod position lelaina!

probably the most on theme entry so far looks great, i like that the pop out is the same texture as the paper and that the colours look a tad faded top vote, well done!

Surely a good imagination, the result looks pretty real couldn't say this has been made on ps

really nice!

nice work a bg would make it cool

nice but i don't think the trees on the outside would have a central crease... good idea though

Very nicely done

This is very nice......G/L Author.

Congrats for your second place, Evan! And also thanks a lot for your congrats for my mod position

thanks

Congrats on your placement!

congrats!! glad it was top 3!!

Congrats!!

Congrats

Now this is a perfect example of a realistic looking pop up book! - an example to everyone that went the wrong direction with this theme. EXCELLENT! you have made me a very happy person indeed! my only criticism is you can see the repetative use of the clone tool on the left hand side on the bg trees... fix that and it's well on the way IMHO.

ok i will fix that when i will wake up , its 4 am here XP

LOL James, relax, dont do it. Nice job author

Doesn't show much dimension, but certainly on theme... Bottom part of tree fold should show a triangular upward element corresponding to the top of the tree.

simple looking image, but absolutely perfect in this contest............ well done, you have my vote

The only realistic one in my opinion

great job!!!

FINALLY!!!!! An entry on theme! I think your dimentions are well done. GL!

perfectly on theme, but you should adjust some details: the pop up shadows are too big - and creates a flying effect to pop-up. then you have to pay more attention on the tree masking on the upper side. good luck!

Good work!

ok i fixed the clone tool effect , thank you all for the suggestions

thats better GL

Beautiful job......G/L Author.

some thing on theme.very well done,good luck

Congrats for your third place, Sophia!

Congrats on your placement!

congratulations on your 3rd place sophia... well deserved!!

Congrats

one of the best so far visually but I don't think it would work as an actual pop up book as the fold for the building is the wrong way isn't it??... it should be the opposite way to the book so that it stands up when opened!?!...

the idea is great, but I have to agree with jamesD, the perspective of the castle is wrong. You should correct the shadow of the castle too.

very good and clear work...

Love this work...very very nice

agrees with jamesD

Congrats

a high-res would be great to view the details, but at least this one is on theme . From this view my only suggestion would be some shadowing behind the popped up elements to show the depth more clearly. Nice image though.

nice one.. bg could have to change

high res would be good... nice visual but without a clearer idea I cant see how any of this would really pop up!?!

Love this work...very very cute....

very nice

The only thing popping up is the owl. You should of angled the book more and had bambi and thumper popping over the edge of the book too.

Congrats