Very nicely done, personally i think the face lets the rest of it down a bit, but overall I really like it. Reply »

Reply:

Not bad. Reply »

Reply:

Very nice rider. Reply »

Reply:

congrats Reply »

Reply:

Congrats, nice work Reply »

Reply:

Congrats,nr1 Reply »

Reply:

congrats so cute Reply »

Reply:

Good job, but fade the near part of the reflection on the floor... Reply »

Reply:

Simple but well chopped. Reply »

Reply:

Congrats! for 2nd Reply »

Reply:

Congrats, Reply »

Reply:

very good... Reply »

Reply:

super cool image but it looks like you only used the doll. you need more of the source Reply »

Reply:

Uber moody, but the dark figure is hard to see against the dark tree... Reply »

Reply:

Very minimal source used. I imagine you are new author and when it comes to source photoshop contests, it's ideal to use a lot more than you have. Reply »

Reply:

... okay, i guess i made a mistake. I'm not new to this site, and i was aware that the provided source could be used in any way, there's not much more of the source i can add to this image, but thanks for your comments. Reply »

Reply:

I would maybe brighten up the Santa thing against the tree. Nice mood. Also use what ever part of the source you want like so many other participants do. Reply »

Reply:

Author, you used the source image. What part you choose to use is up to you, and IMHO you used it well. Reply »

Reply:

Thank you very much Nator and CMYK. Nator - i brightened up the Santa as much as i could, but unfortunately the .PSD file was corrupt, and so i had to do it straight on the JPEG. I hope it still looks okay. Reply »

Reply:

Finall result is great but this is minimal use of source... Reply »

Reply:

congrats matteo! Reply »

Reply:

Congrats! for 3rd place Reply »

Reply:

Congrats, Reply »

Reply:

great idea, innitially i thought you used the doors to make the trees Reply »

Reply:

Good idea! Perspective on the desk thing is off, and what's the red thing on the escalator? Reply »

Reply:

Thanks CMYK,that red thing on the escalator is the Santa from the source image... Reply »

Reply:

Nice - maybe make the clouds more transparent where Santa is Reply »

Reply:

Love the idea, very original, I think the doors look to out of place, perhaps a border of clouds around them or even fading the edges might help. Fix that and strighten the desk and you'll have a great image Reply »

Reply:

Thanks for the tips guys...CMYK perspective is fixed,Nator i think that clouds around Santa now have more depth and Ray,i add door cloud borders.I hope its better now.Thanks again guys.... Reply »

Reply:

Perspective isn't fixed...all images are straight on except for the desk which is angled left. Reply »

Reply:

Agrees with the perspective but I think a better fix would be some more feathering on the bottom edge. It just seems a little hard, compared to the doors that you got right. I think santa's face should be a little lit more visable. For what it's worth, your imagination and creativity, as well as a unique entry will earn you extra points. Reply »

Reply:

haha this is such a good idea Reply »

Reply:

Kid is way too small compared to the doors... Reply »

Reply:

That kid doesnt really want to bang his head into the shelf either I can fix him a bit larger,... Hope this is better
Reply »

Reply:

Looks like mist... Reply »

Reply:

nice work with the water,but the light on the back of the kid dont match the room Reply »

Reply:

sophia, yes,, i know, but i didnt think it would be noticed because of the water. Reply »

Reply:

Nice image. IMO you could remove the kid entirely. Reply »

Reply:

The waterfall and image really needed attention. They could have been cropped better. There's is no way not to notice the bright light on the back of the kid and I think your best bet would have been to find another kid source. Reply »

Reply: