This is almost perfect! Amazing Render. I just have the feeling it's a bit stretched out vertically. Reply »

Reply:

I'm sorry to say this and I really am sorry if I'm wrong but, this to me after some revising of the both photographs looks fake.. meaning you took the original photo and just made a simple sbs.. Reply »

Reply:

I just looked at your sbs and it seems you did do the modeling but you sort of overlayed the original photograph onto your model.. and I'm not sure if thats allowed is it? I mean it sort of cheating isn't it? Reply »

Reply:

I guess your right I wasnt even aware of a technique like this but to me it just seems pointless what you've done.. because it's just identical, but only because you used the actual photo as a texture, i think the whole theme in here is to yes, copy the image but using your own textures. Anyway well see if the mods have a problem with it either way good luck and sorry if i sounded like bitchy or something :P Reply »

Reply:

I understand it is annoying if you see an entry that you do not know how it is done, but the oppotunity to learn is there. If it is as simple as you make out thenhave a go it is an open contest that is about 3d and all its tricks and skills not about searching the web for matching pre made textures and shaders. If it is on theme I will write a tutorial as this is one of the most commonly used ways to texture VFX shots.

Thanks Reply »

Reply:

Wow, who needs a camera. Reply »

Reply:

Excellent work, great texturing. Reply »

Reply:

thanks everybody Reply »

Reply:

Good thinking out or the box.. Reply »

Reply:

Great job I did 'lol' at the cheat remark... Understanding the baking process on its own is a process the author has had to learn - so to call a cheat or imply that this is simple to do is a little insulting. On another note - I would very much like to see a tutorial on this process as I haven't had the time to explore it. GL author, a clear win from me. Reply »

Reply:

the picture was overlayed or is the same, stretched a bit... even spoted the fat spot on the edge of the pages. make a render from a different angle and i will accept this is a baked texture and a camera projection. Also.. your geometry for the pages in the sbs is smooth, you don't have jagged edges. Show me displacement maps for those.

PS: for the clone account .. sry.. the other person.. this is not the winner. Specialy having this contest for another week to run. Dude.. stop commenting so much on your own entries. IT'S ANNOYING! Reply »

Reply:

@ mirjea I have uploaded as step 4 of SBS different angles. there are no diplacement maps because what you are seeing is texture in the colour channel. I am a little confused because I have not done anything wrong, in fact I have forfilled the brief of the contest may be a little to well and so am getting a lot of stick for doing my best to explain to people what is going on and show that I am not cheating.

I would like to point out the MODs seem to have no problem with it.

last comment i wouldn't want to be annoying. Though I think people who do not know what they are talking about being rude and accusatory is a little annoying, but hay better to be a lover than a hater eh! Reply »

Reply:

Wow - photo realistic image. It's very close to what real life pencil is. Well done Reply »

Reply:

Very nicely done, excellent job. Reply »

Reply:

Saw the extra SBS... my mistake author. You would have avoided all this fuss if you would have entered that from the start. Good camera projection and great technique.

My appologies Reply »

Reply:

thanks Reply »

Reply:

I'll admit you did a terrific job. Unfortunately, I don't buy it. At the end of the day, I'm still looking at your source image, not your geometry, texture, etc,.. You've cleverly found a loophole in the wording of this contest, as it doesn't state that you may not use the source, and for that you deserve 1st. Bravo. Bravo. Reply »

Reply:

I must admit that although this is a new technique to me, I totally understand how it works. I also question wether this is valid or not in this competition.

I would like to hear from a MOD on this matter, for not only this contest, but contests that are still to come.

In my opinion when the contest description is asking to MIMIC a photo by means of "Background, lighting, shading, texture and obviously model etc" the entry should contain all of these but be recreated, thus it becomes a mimic, a recreation - not a duplication.

Does this scene have any light setup for example?... no.
Reply »

Reply:

Amazing!! Fantastic render! congrats!!
Reply »

Reply:

I don't know 3d, but this is sure as realistic as I have ever seen. Reply »

Reply:

awsm render!! good luck author Reply »

Reply:

Congrats, wonderful work Reply »

Reply:

Great, but the sbs is impossible to read! Reply »

Reply:

I agree, fantastic work, but that font, color and size don't work. There is room to type your info in the sbs box, where it would be legible. I like that you even got some texture on the pencil. Reply »

Reply:

Realistic and very pleasing! Love the textures! Reply »

Reply:

Congrats for 2nd too Reply »

Reply:

Good job! You beat me to it. Nice modelling and render. Reply »

Reply:

Really nice work, down to the subtle wood grain on the pencil tip.
The overall lighting is a bit too bright, but the excellent rendering makes that a somewhat moot point. Very well done! Reply »

Reply:

super nice! Reply »

Reply:

Thank you all for the wonderful comments! Reply »

Reply:

I get the feeling a few people will choose this one for their model. Mostly this is accurate and a good job Reply »

Reply:

Thanks :P Yeah it seems the simplest one yet it still has some challenging parts to model... Reply »

Reply:

A good one. I like the texture work. Reply »

Reply:

Congrats for 3rd Reply »

Reply:

The tip of the pencil is too sharp, and the outside painted edge where it is sharpened is too angular - it needs to be more rounded. Also, the bright highlight on the side is out of place and inconsistent with the rest of the image. Otherwise, this is a very good render! Reply »

Reply:

nice Reply »

Reply:

Thanks Reply »

Reply:

Nice work, good job on the metal part of the pencil. Reply »

Reply:

ditto ^ abt d metal part..really good job!! Reply »

Reply:

Reply »

Reply: