Very beautiful work...GL

Beautiful..I really like it , Just try lighten the brush effect a bit- looks like a smugde (in the middle of the image) GL

Cool...very sci-fi feeling to it GL

ghostly fun.. great thinking !!!!

sweet.. elegant and gentle image.. kudos

(Considering how explosive the original image was.. really is a neat contrast)

Congrats

congratulations on your 3rd place sophia... well deserved!!

Congrats on your placement!

Congrats for your third place, Sophia!

some thing on theme.very well done,good luck

Beautiful job......G/L Author.

thats better GL

Good work!

perfectly on theme, but you should adjust some details: the pop up shadows are too big - and creates a flying effect to pop-up. then you have to pay more attention on the tree masking on the upper side. good luck!

FINALLY!!!!! An entry on theme! I think your dimentions are well done. GL!

great job!!!

simple looking image, but absolutely perfect in this contest............ well done, you have my vote

Doesn't show much dimension, but certainly on theme... Bottom part of tree fold should show a triangular upward element corresponding to the top of the tree.

LOL James, relax, dont do it. Nice job author

Now this is a perfect example of a realistic looking pop up book! - an example to everyone that went the wrong direction with this theme. EXCELLENT! you have made me a very happy person indeed! my only criticism is you can see the repetative use of the clone tool on the left hand side on the bg trees... fix that and it's well on the way IMHO.

Looks good except for conflicting light sources...

I like this one, well done on the effect of the hand coming out of the ground. The background with the trees doesnt fit imo though, given how dry and baron the foreground is.

Congratulations!

Congratulations!

Congrats!

Congrats!

Congrats

Congrats

Congrats on your placement!

Congrats!

Congrats,

congrats with first, real nice image

Congrats for your second place, Sophia!

Congrats,nr1

Congrats for your first place, Sophia!

very creative . nice concept ...

One of the better entries I've seen so far so good luck. Why private comments????

Not unique...

nice underwater scene. it could use some warmer colors though. Good luck

I guess you would have to call it fantasy to account for the floating tower on the left. Unique idea.

Great fantasy work! The water looks very nice too!

great job

Beautiful!

Dreat image, Good luck!

Apart from the ocean, amazing work and nicely done

Good fantasy image...

The castle is really nice, but I think the perspective on the sea waves is wrong.

A little late but congrats on your 1st place. This was always my choice for 1st.

beautiful design.Gongrats on 1st place!

try to change curves and levels