18 comments given:
no avatar
Menelve says:

Awesome picture! But yes you do need to post your source (the current link is bad) and make sure your source is copyright free (cause the url for the link gave me the impression that it's from a news site which would be copyrighted). Good luck!

(5 years and 1999 days ago)

Bank Of Nile
no avatar
Menelve says:

I love the lightbulbs! nicely done!

(5 years and 2002 days ago)

Golden carousel
no avatar
Menelve says:

Clever and well excuted! However, the background really detracts from the gorgeous fairy. Please put something there, it will make your rank go up.

(5 years and 2117 days ago)

Berry Fairy
no avatar
Menelve says:

Nice choice, however you need to polish your masking/coloring. It's not right.

(5 years and 2140 days ago)

Single Flower
no avatar
Menelve says:

you are perfectly allowed to chop the photo. All the guidelines say is to "make a photo in black in white" which means chops are allowed.

(5 years and 2140 days ago)

yellow snow
no avatar
Menelve says:

Yes it does. A chop counts. Nicely done! the bow definitely stands out.

(5 years and 2140 days ago)

Red Bow
no avatar
Menelve says:

Very cute! The reflections are a nice touch.

(5 years and 2147 days ago)

Branch and rock
no avatar
Menelve says:

nice on the touching up, but the face is too clearly cut out. Needs a neck and the area beside her right eye is too black for there being hair behind her.

(5 years and 2236 days ago)

Hooded
no avatar
Menelve says:

I love what you did here!

(5 years and 2236 days ago)

Antique
no avatar
Menelve says:

Nice! very subtle.

(5 years and 2236 days ago)

This That
no avatar
Menelve says:

yah, it's nice but you need to do more than color it. Also, please put up the before image as well (split image) cause it's mandatory for this contest. *points to contest description*

(5 years and 2236 days ago)

Red Beauty
no avatar
Menelve says:

her eyes do look a bit stretched, but I like what you've done here!

(5 years and 2236 days ago)

Hottie
no avatar
Menelve says:

much better! good work!

(5 years and 2246 days ago)

Lake House
no avatar
Menelve says:

lol that's great! One thing, the word "bluish" on the yellow crayon doesn't match. You did a good job of matching text on the white crayon, though!

(5 years and 2246 days ago)

Bluish Blue
no avatar
Menelve says:

Nice! most of your elements are blending well. However, the grass is too sharp/bright and the same goes for the pillars of the dock. The perspective is a little off for the bench, but I don't know if you can fix it. The rest looks great though!

(5 years and 2246 days ago)

Lake House
no avatar
Menelve says:

looks much better now! the pirates could still do with having the dodge tool applied to them to make their right side more shadowed.

(5 years and 2246 days ago)

Pirate
no avatar
Menelve says:

nice work! but still needs some polishing. Ditto on the desaturating CMYK. I'd also add that the light sources are wrong. you have the moon in the back, but no shadows. the pirate on the right should be almost completely in the shadow of the boat as of where the moon is, for example.

(5 years and 2251 days ago)

Pirate