Nice change ... I like the way the one boat is lit by the moon. I think there would be some light on the water (especially where the wave is peaking/hitting the beach ... it could even be used to draw the eye into the image). Just a thought!

Great suggestion Arca, thanks. I was thinking the same thing. Edit made.

Light source is from upper right. Shadows match that source, not the one you've made.

i disagree with ya ky

Love the change ... I liked it but like it even more now ... very nice change! Love the people out Moonbathing ... maybe they are all waiting for an eclipse!

Sorry, but the light source in the original pic is way up on the right.

Classical approach Proper use of all those Ps adjustment tools !!! Step 4 is a must, who needs strong highlights at night

Very effective, great mood! The clouds almost seem to move.

cmyk1234142 bla bla bla is right! not often, but this time! needs shadow work!

Very very nice work author...mood is great...this look like maybe hour before sunrise with heavy rain clouds...well done

very pretty

Sigh, what I would do to see this type of lighting in REAL LIFE.. with so much city light it's hard to find (though it is kind of cool when Turtle season is happening down here in Florida they shut off all the beach lights and just let the moon be on it's own, and all the little teenagers guarding sections of beach, it's a hoot (good luck author, nice work)

Really nice work, author, all those adjustments made for a very effective change. I have been on those very beaches, and this looks incredibly realistic. Love moonbaths!