artsy, great image!!

very liquid flow all over the place.. comes together quite nicely.. even if it is a dark subject.. it's very pretty .. good luck

Mood is nice

really nice image

great

Amazing!

like the tone and mood

nice done!

Scary but nice, good job author very unique entry.

i love this image. great!!

Great entry!

Really well done! There's a hollowness going on at the feet. Like it needs more density. Otherwise...excellent

Super.

creative use of the source nice job!

Congrats! Very well done.

Congratulations for 1st

Congrats, well done

congrats!

congrats

congrats!!

CONGRAAATS!!!!!

Congrats for 1st

Congrats!

very nice entry. good colors

Can I see a higher quality version please? Nice work and idea here but I was to appreciate it properly

very nice mood

very nice mood

very nice mood

Good mood. If you flip your background, it will match the light source on the original image.

Good composition and nice colors...........Good luck Author.

Very Nice and I love the mood!!

looks real good work author

beautiful

I agree with CMYK - your posts would be casting shadows, not lit from the front as they are now.. Nice mood though.

Your sources dont seem to check out?? I got a google page for the first and a blog for the second?? Do you have the original image holders permissions to use the image??

well i have entered the links i hv used....i dont seem to have any probs wid opening them :O

Nice color choice of a duotone feel.

This image has a nice feel to it

Nice scene like all the blue tones works well!

beautiful. GL! 1st place, I guess

Congrats! Very well done.

Congratulations for 2nd

Congratulations.

congrats!

congrats

congrats!!

Congrats on 2nd!

Congrats!

) nice one, i love ur cats, good luck

author.. Are those Fish Bones in the shoreline????.. if they aren't .. they sure should be.. LOL.. and if they were just something you added as an after thought.. they are absolutely brilliant.. I loved the whole piece.. going kitty to kitty, but when I saw the fish bones.. I just had to laugh.. GREAT JOB!!!

AHHHHHH the little one.. I missed the little kitty.. he's staring at the dragon fly LOLOLOL.. WOW

Yes, the 'Watch' is for their next dinner. I thought the fish bones were a fun touch here.

Brilliant, those structures now seem as meant to be cats. And the fishbones are a really funny touch!

Haha funny stuff and nice work - My cat would not be seen anywhere near the surf! There seems to be patches of colour in the rocks in the foreground? Also the third cat in from the right is too transparent - you can see the post through him. Nice though.

Thanks, annimax. I worked on the rather transparent kitty. Color in foreground was unchanged from original source except to add a little contrast to source photo in general. I kind of like a bit of color there to go with colors in 'bodies'. I know it's not perfect, but spent so much time on this project that I'm beginning to get seasick!!!!!! AND my cat would not enjoy this at all either!!! Now I see I lost my dragonflies, so will have to get back in the water. OH, well.

fantastic eye to see how each lighting effect on each rock could be a part of the cat facing one direction or another. FANTASTIC!

So cute kittens , nice job

hehe nice idea! Good Luck

lol

Creative entry........G/L Author.

Much better

kewl

good work

cool cats GL

Interesting image.

very cute

Your Cat is famous now...LOL...great image and very nice color. GL

Aw they so cute,,,,

hehe cats.

Great creativity top work!

Congrats! Very well done.

Congratulations for 3rd

Congratulations.

congrats!

congrats!!

Congrats for 3rd!

Happy to see you got 3rd!

Congrats!

Congrats!

very nice entry. like the mood. only the wave, too bright

Thanks, but I like the brightness as it was gives the image its mood

VERY COOL... I WANNA go there

Amazing! Would never think about his It's really well done.

lovely.....nice mood.....

The wave is a bit too bright to me, too...and the light source on the objects is from the right, not from behind where you have a light source.

I like the way you used the source.Beautiful image

CMYK i appreciate you observations but I beleive the stong moon light and luminous stones is sufficeint to create bounced light on the left rock.

remember CMYK anything is possible in a make beleive scene!

cool...

Nice mood!

Nice mood...beaut sky!

nice mood B)

nice idea!! G/L

nice work, good luck

Congrats! Very well done.

you did very well

Love the result. Very good job. GL

nice imagination.....jst bottom edged of tat standing things need some more work.....it also need shadows....GL

Good Work, nicely done

Thats very creative

Well done, matches perfectly Good blend.

i really like it

simple, but good

Not sure about the wet look of the wood, wouldn't it be dry in the desert?

nice blending

you did very well