great work
nice mood and colors Reply »

Reply:

Beautiful...instant fav Reply »

Reply:

thanks guys Reply »

Reply:

great image!! Reply »

Reply:

Very, very nice!!!! Instant fav! Reply »

Reply:

I liked his art but would like to see your SBS. Congratulations! Reply »

Reply:

Background is too dark compared to the figure and reduces the illusion of depth. If you want to add yellow lanterns to the image, there would be yellow highlights on the figure. (Which would also nicely pull it forward from the background). Reply »

Reply:

CMYK46 - Well, she is not close enough to be lightning like you're suggesting.. neither from yellow lamps or the window.. I think you should improve your lightning skills before to critique another one. thanks for your commenting anyway... Reply »

Reply:

Reply »

Reply:

Author, if you're content with a flat image that's fine with me. For the lanterns to be that far back they are disproportionately large compared to the figure. I will vote accordingly. Reply »

Reply:

CMYK46 - Yes I'm happy with my picture and after checking your gallery I think you should try to be better in image edition instead of wasting your time making stupid comments like that. Thanks for your vote. Reply »

Reply:

Awesome. Love it! Reply »

Reply:

Author, this section is for comments on the work, not for personal attacks, which are expressly forbidden in the PXL guidelines. Reply »

Reply:

That is not an attack imo it is an observation and a suggestion. Reply »

Reply:

Agree with cabl and you author...too much talk out of the same culprit all the time.Once in a while is ok but constantly is asinine. HIGH vote from a HIGH vote power voter...great image irregardless of what the PXL resident critic says. Love the color and the mood. Reply »

Reply:

Masterpiece!!!...love it. Reply »

Reply:

nice.... mysterious-looking.

only can suggest: lift up the wings' angle, now quite horizontal.
can use 'liquidfy' to make wings more beautiful.. like birds' Reply »

Reply:

thanks for all comments, I'm open to suggestions not to critiques.. theres a big difference Reply »

Reply:

I think she has a great bottom Reply »

Reply:

Great image author, i agree with everyone, except cmyk. Reply »

Reply:

Good job. I like the style.

Small suggestion: blurr the lanterns a little. They are too sharp compared to the arch and window. Reply »

Reply:

fantastic work author..gl
Reply »

Reply:

i do love this image. is there a hi res/sbs?
and, i am going to be the person to agree with cmyk a little on this one.
if you want the lanterns to be further into the background as to not put a light reflection onto the girl, then they need to match the blurring done to the background and give it more depth. also adding some of that yellow lighting to the walls so that it "fits".
if you choose to leave them where they are, then they would leave some yellow lighting on the girl. not ALOT but there would be some.
there is a strange white-ish artifact on the viewers right hand side, also. Reply »

Reply:

Jade, be careful...she's a sensitive "artiste" and will go off on you... Reply »

Reply:

nice work, only i see that light on the right is more blurred than the left one
and i like her ass too Reply »

Reply:

@CMYK - I dont have problems with jade despite of she's only a photographer and doesnt understand too much about edition.. My problem is with you who doesnt stopp critique the others and doesnt look at his own ass.. I mean, are you still here? you're wasting your time.. go searching photomanipulation tutorials at google.. this way you get better so you'll see how hard is to blend perfectly a picture. Reply »

Reply:

Ummmm. Check my portfolio. I actually am not JUST a photographer. you might surprise yourself to know that photomanipulations are my main reason for being here.
My advice was constructive and not insulting. I would still like to see a high res and an sbs. In high res I am sure I could get a better grasp on why you remain so set on leaving the lamps as in focus as they are while the rest of your background is such a blur.
And..that little white thing...likely a remnant from some erasing on one of your layers...its driving me crazy.
Your work is nice, but none of us are perfect. Reply »

Reply:

Great job,good luck author ! Reply »

Reply:

The girl is superbe and so weel done, but i think you might cancel the two lights because they are not essential in this pics and are subject of a lot of critics, very very good work author and good luck. Reply »

Reply:

As the Author you don't have to agree with suggestions about your work, you can create your image as you want. The suggestions made by CMYK46 and jadedink are academic and technically accurate and are in no way insulting. Your response is unfair and inaccurate to say the least. CMYK46 has the background and experience plus a long record of helping members improve their entries. Jadedink is much more than a photographer, she's proven to be a talented artist and a skilled "chopper". Suggestions are what helps members learn and improve and should be accepted in the spirit they were given. I do like your entry very much but It's a basic rule, never isolate a color. This hurts the rhythm of a composition, by adding the yellow reflected on the figure the eye will keep moving through the composition. Reply »

Reply:

You are getting a high vote from me also, because I like your image but I also do think there would be a bit of yellow in the floor shine. Author it really is best not to get upset with the critics who mean to help. But of course you do not have to change anything ,that is up to your discretion, best to say nothing and let people vote as they feel. ( they will anyway ) But then you will not come across as a whiner. Disagreements should not be dragged on and on. Reply »

Reply:

Congrats, well done Reply »

Reply:

Congratulations Author Reply »

Reply:

Well done congratulations! Reply »

Reply:

congrats... Reply »

Reply:

Congrats!!! Reply »

Reply:

Congrats Reply »

Reply:

nice blending -- lighting is well done Reply »

Reply:

Thank you, Alan! Reply »

Reply:

very impressive work author.now i can guess your entry by your work.good luck author

Reply »

Reply:

Thank you, Kush!! Reply »

Reply:

I really like this effect, but the yellow cloud seems too heavy on the right, with not quite enough on the left... Reply »

Reply:

Thank you, MossyB!! Reply »

Reply:

Hi
U got a gr8 creativity Reply »

Reply:

Thank you, Sagar!!! Reply »

Reply:

Nice image. Well composed, i like the mood. Reply »

Reply:

Thank you, Dust... Reply »

Reply:

nice mood! Reply »

Reply:

nice work \o Reply »

Reply:

Thank you, guys! \o/ Reply »

Reply:

nice work gl author..!! Reply »

Reply:

Thank you!!! Reply »

Reply:

beautiful work author..... GL!! Reply »

Reply:

lovely
Reply »

Reply:

Thank you all guys! You are awesome!!! \o/ Reply »

Reply:

8 Favs (so far), well done! I smell winner winner, chicken dinner! Reply »

Reply:

Huahuahau.... funny!!!

I don't know, I don't know... will see!!!

Thank you very much !! Reply »

Reply:

good work author... Reply »

Reply:

Thanks neo! Reply »

Reply:

the black theatre boarders really add to the mood! Reply »

Reply:

Thank you Driven!!! Reply »

Reply:

Congrats ! Reply »

Reply:

congrats... Reply »

Reply:

Thank you guys!!! Reply »

Reply:

not very heavenly feel... should have light, angels, white clouds, music....

change title Reply »

Reply:

Nice composition, but you still have the original reflection on the ground. Reply »

Reply:

Nice catch solkee... I fixed it
thanks!!. Reply »

Reply:

I have to disagree with you aheman..I think sometimes you dont have to put exact things to make it that obvious.. I could do what you suggest but at this time Im taking this pic simple and with good taste.
Thanks for the comment!. Reply »

Reply:

I like this ...perfectly simple Reply »

Reply:

congrats... Reply »

Reply:

Thanks Kushpatel!.. Reply »

Reply:

Congrats author!!! Reply »

Reply:

You should tear out a section of the roof ribbing - it looks too "perfect" for all the debris on the bottom. Reply »

Reply:

Wow! Very convincing! Well done. Reply »

Reply:

You might consider taking out some of the ceiling ribbing. to better match all the destruction and rubble. The roof is still too "perfect" looking. Reply »

Reply:

Nice Blend Author.. Good Luck! Reply »

Reply:

Good job; looks convincing (may be you could flip the background so it matches the direction of light on the church). Reply »

Reply:

Good job, well blended (May be you can flip the background to match the lighting direction). Reply »

Reply:

Well done, believable result. Nitpick would be that the background buildings get their light from the opposite compared to the foreground, but that would be a matter of flipping. The mess in front fits well, nice masking. Good luck! Reply »

Reply:

Wow, good idea and lots of tedious work here, nice chopping (literally)! Reply »

Reply:

Really great work with the ceiling. I like the way the stars and clouds show through. Good image! Reply »

Reply:

Dreamy scene!!! I liked! Love the colors... Good Luck author. Reply »

Reply:

Thank you both Reply »

Reply:

good entry, shadows are not from the light source , maybe try to get that Reply »

Reply:

Love this scene,good luck author ! Reply »

Reply: