Very nice and very interesting to see your new entry ^^. I just have a small suggestion of erasing the black strokes around some fishes, this can be seen clearly in the HiRes. Best of luck to you

I really like this one. I especially like how you created the ocean surface (being viewed from below) and the ocean floor as well. langstrum is right about the fish strokes, but again, only on close inspection. My only other nit-picky critique (again, only noticeable in hi-res) would be the pearls by the oyster. They seem to be floating instead of lying on the ocean floor. Maybe some shading or scaling? Just a thought. You have a great command of lighting. Impressive work overall.

thank you for your comments, I will try to fix the fish asap Thanks again, much appreciated!
EDIT: I tried to get rid of the black strokes... I hope this is better

nice job but i think it will be more realistic if you put the algae in the side of the image or if you cut the trunk but still nice idea

beautiful

Outstanding!

sheeesh... thank you guys for the comments and Favs

Good job!

Grrrreattt job....

Nice idea to turn the tree into a sea- weed