very good idea -- maybe some blur on the cut edges (Tops) of the books would improve this as they seem too sharp compared to the edges of the towels used for the spines of the books.

cool idea... but looks faded-foggy. You can use "curves" to jazz-up the colors

very clever

Great idea and takes lot of time to do it I would say. Only thing, it's too blurry and looks like not the real thing. If you can do something to correct this, believe me, your entry will get to the top. That's my personal opinion. Good luck author!

Great manipulation. Probably having "gradual" shadow for each bookshelf section to show the depth and very transparent reflection of the shorter books might make the image a bit more realistic. And also, having shadow that match the overall image for the ladder that fall of the books might also help?

very good hard work!

Clever concept, I would take the advice about shadows though a few little tweaks will make all the difference. Well done and GL

wonderful work

A bit too cut and paste with the color patterns too repeated and regular. This would be stronger if you flipped the repeats and used Hue and Saturation to vary the colors somewhat.

i just selling idea! It's more enough for me!

If you're here for the fun of it then it looks fine. If you are here to learn and improve and get higher scores, then MossyB is correct.

i just wants to be fun & share idea only........don't be so serious...........anyway thanks for your advise......

The blue stripes by the mouth are inconsistent with the rest of the image - They look like some are growing out of her face, with only one coming out of her mouth, but the blue lower lip makes that look weird, as well. The blur on the left hand side doesn't help. This just doesn't illustrate your concept as well as it could.

Might be better to make the blue stuff transparent, and clean up the upper edge of her arm.

I like the sepia feel allowing the colorful source show even more prominent.

More of a minor addition than a manipulation, I would expect more based on the level of entries already in the contest, best of luck though

Brilliant!

idea is there... but should add a "wow" or "oh!" feel..

suggest.. let the zoom-in bugs make funny faces, like sticking out their tongues

I like your humor and good thinking! Nice job.

Without and SBS there is really know way to tell you how to fix the distortion issues on the sitting person. Distort/Warp/Puppet could help correct the odd body angles(his faded outline edges are a bit weird compared to the rest of the realism in the room.. also the lack of shadows cast by the standing figure makes him float...

While the concept (love the room walls) is quite good, the execution is a bit muddled. A little tender care might help this image a lot. (Good Luck)

at Level 10.. we would expect a little more... u didn't do shadows, juzt cut-n-paste.. it will be difficult gain votes

I know it doesn't sound good to hear, but just a frank comment, hope u not angry