158 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The blending makes the sand look transparent & the bottle needs a shadow. Light source is in low right background, but the strong light on the woman is from the left.

(5 years and 2045 days ago)

Castaway
no avatar
Anusha1 says:

Great work

(5 years and 2045 days ago)

Castaway
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 2407 days ago)

The planet
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The edges of the mushrooms are also very ragged looking and poorly cut out in the stem area. The line along the top of the breast is particularly choppy looking and rough edged. All of the elements show a dark outline of 1-2 pixels, except for the top front of the woman's headdress, which shows a very disconcerting white edge on the face side, and a strange dark "blob" on the back. This visible extraction outline can be corrected if you contract your selection by 1 pixel, invert your selection, and then delete.

(5 years and 2414 days ago)

The planet
avatar Drivenslush

so pretty and sweet!!!

(5 years and 2414 days ago)

The planet
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

There should be shadows on the head from the headdress, and the edges of her skin are ragged. Yellow cast in foreground & background kills depth.

(5 years and 2414 days ago)

The planet
avatar madamemonty

Congrats, wonderful work

(5 years and 2434 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Congrats!

(5 years and 2434 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar spaceranger

Congrats!!

(5 years and 2434 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar nicehotcupoftea

Congratulations on first place

(5 years and 2434 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Love this, author! My only nitpick would be that the blood dripping from her mouth would be darker. Maybe you could burn it a little. The flame and sparks for hair is wild!

(5 years and 2440 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar Akassa
Akassa says:

Amazing effect and blending, great job.

(5 years and 2445 days ago)

Vulcano
no avatar
Keiley22 says:

looks like that lady gaga creature lol

(5 years and 2446 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Needs more sources (such as blood from mouth) or SBS. A blur at our right of the face, too. Good image otherwise.

(5 years and 2446 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar Drivenslush

hehehe, I'd love to go out with you but I've got to wash my hair.. LOLOL.. fun fun image

(5 years and 2446 days ago)

Vulcano
avatar George55
George55 says:

Great colors and composition. Good luck author!

(5 years and 2611 days ago)

Fire in your arms again
avatar jordyponce

Love the colors..nice entry GL!!..

(5 years and 2612 days ago)

Fire in your arms again
avatar tnaylor21286

I love the composition of this piece. Good luck author!

(5 years and 2614 days ago)

Fire in your arms again
avatar ShiZa
ShiZa says:

#like this! nice colours, great composition! mabye you should change some leafs to the painting style, to get a more harmonic image. but thats just me

(5 years and 2616 days ago)

Fire in your arms again
no avatar
jakex16 says:

this is beautiful artwork

(5 years and 2616 days ago)

Fire in your arms again
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 2617 days ago)

Shot in waves
avatar pixelkid
pixelkid says:

This is a really nice composition. Kinda wish the edges were a little bit less sharp and a bit softer. Great job, author!

(5 years and 2621 days ago)

Shot in waves
avatar bjaockx
bjaockx says:

why the flowers are so blurry is beyond me. i mean i know why they are blurred, but there is no reason for it other than laziness. While i like the idea of your composition, and some of the other issues have already been touched on, i will mention the flowers. They are blurred because you made the first ones small to place onto the tree and did not duplicate yourself an original of the larger sized flowers. then when you resized the small flowers to big ones it made them blurry. always save an original layer you can go back to with your objects.

(5 years and 2625 days ago)

Roots in beauty
avatar bjaockx
bjaockx says:

The hair looks like it took some time to do, and looks great. the rest of the images, not so much. In future works, pay attention to your masking and i always suggest using the pen tool as it works on mathematical formulas to create smooth precise lines, which will prevent your masked objects from getting sharp jagged edges. Very creative work! God luck!

(5 years and 2625 days ago)

Shot in waves
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The roots look to be in front of the body, making a very odd visual image, since she has no lower body, no left hand, and no rear end...
The forearm also appears to be overly thinned from the elbow down to the wrist.

(5 years and 2625 days ago)

Roots in beauty
avatar Eladine
Eladine says:

very artistic!

(5 years and 2625 days ago)

Shot in waves
avatar SHIPLEYGIRL

that is so very cool

(5 years and 2625 days ago)

Shot in waves
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Transition between the roots & body is dubious. Where's her left hand? Daisies just look like an add-on to the image.

(5 years and 2630 days ago)

Roots in beauty
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Interesting image...would be better if you got rid of the white outline on the head & shoulder.

(5 years and 2640 days ago)

Incandescent mask
avatar Drivenslush

very happy chop

(5 years and 2650 days ago)

Crying guitar
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

There's an abrupt cutoff line on the light rays at left, white edges around the prow of the boat, the reflection of the guitar is at the wrong angle, and the water is just overlaid on the foreground.

(5 years and 2650 days ago)

Crying guitar
avatar Eladine
Eladine says:

good idea, the style of the image is not my taste, but thats personal i dont think the images go nice together but others might like this style

(5 years and 2675 days ago)

nameless
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

You could have found some barrels as sources anywhere. The rest is just the usual DA pics. Good luck on your collage.

(5 years and 2675 days ago)

nameless
no avatar

well one can see the work you have dedicated to this.. But i see a small mistake.. the Perceptive of the girls legs ( Ankles) to the height of the rim of the barrel dosn't match pretty well... And the 2nd barrel behind looks as if its kept as an image on the background then as a single picture...

Anyways GL Author

(5 years and 2678 days ago)

nameless
avatar orientallad

Congratulations on third

(5 years and 2686 days ago)

Electricity Queen
avatar pixelkid
pixelkid says:

Creative use of the source. A nice change up from the pack! It would be nice if you could possibly curl the paper to more of the contour of what the face would provide. Nice work, nonetheless!

(5 years and 2701 days ago)

Krimminelle
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Tower needs a shadow. Maybe you should add about a hundred more balloons...

(5 years and 2705 days ago)

Where to go?
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The smoke brush would look more effective if the newspaper looked like it was burning somewhere. As is, there is no real source for the smoke.

(5 years and 2706 days ago)

Krimminelle
avatar rsguetre
rsguetre says:

Really good idea, beautiful colours! However the honey flowing over her shoulder looks like it's just sprayed on colour (blurry edges)

(5 years and 2709 days ago)

Miss Honey
avatar Drivenslush

love the hair confusion

(5 years and 2711 days ago)

Miss Honey
avatar JimLemon
JimLemon says:

Sweet! Hehehe OK, bad joke but good entry!

(5 years and 2712 days ago)

Miss Honey
avatar Eladine
Eladine says:

May i suggest this tutorial to make ur bubble brush, http://www.cgarena.com/freestuff/tutorials/photoshop/soapbubbles/index2.html cus its not alowed to use other peoples illustrations o.o;

(5 years and 2712 days ago)

Miss Honey
avatar pixelkid
pixelkid says:

Somehow this would make a great CD or album cover. It has just enough color and randomness to be modern and prevalent. Nice job! I love the all the random drippers in the hair.

(5 years and 2713 days ago)

Miss Honey
avatar BillRichards

Talking about a sticky situation...

(5 years and 2713 days ago)

Miss Honey
no avatar
featherst says:

I really like this one!

(5 years and 2714 days ago)

Miss Honey
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

The line of the drip that runs across the nose doesn't conform to the contours of the face, and the light sources on the stems of the drippers are inconsistent. Also, as translucent as they are, the honey drips would have shadows.Good idea otherwise.

(5 years and 2714 days ago)

Miss Honey
no avatar
ps.robgd says:

Beautiful image. Maybe some hard highlights on the arm to simulate honey better. Succes in continuare!

(5 years and 2714 days ago)

Miss Honey
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 2743 days ago)

Mixed seasons
no avatar

love surrel images.. pitty about the SBS missing.

(5 years and 2745 days ago)

Mixed seasons
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

No hi-res or SBS? Hmmm...

(5 years and 2747 days ago)

Mixed seasons