interesting I like it

Nice.

Great colour and movement to this well done

Interesting image!

Great sourcing and really nice use.
As wazowski pointed out you could do a bit more with the light...if you made the sky a bit more dynamic you could use the light from that to accentuate other parts of the image and therefore make it look more cohesive.

I'd personally like this much more if the framed picture wasn't here...or maybe at least if the saturation of it matched the muted tones of the rest of the image.

I use that basic method so often I have it set up as an action

Nice!
I wish the cat looked slightly wetter, though I'm not sure how exactly you would achieve the effect? Also maybe a bit of backlighting?

Good work! I would only suggest using a smaller brush/sample size for the flames as I think that would add to the realism. But maybe that's just me

Nice idea. The smudge tool is your friend!

Nicely done but so little of the source was used

Nice. Good job on the lighting and reflections. The hat seems to stand out a bit too much somehow?