532 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 2709 days ago)

prisoner of the knowledge
avatar minnie
minnie says:

Nice concept and image, good luck authort!

(5 years and 2710 days ago)

prisoner of the knowledge
no avatar

oH how this depicts my life.. LOL

GREAT CONCEPT!

The previous posters have highlighted and stated weill.

(5 years and 2710 days ago)

prisoner of the knowledge
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The line of the corner is hurting the composition. It is too bright, and is dividing the visual plane, segregating the figure. The line of books lead the eye out of the image, through the window, with nothing to bring it back in except the heavy and oppressive black walls. While effective, the overall feel is quite confined, rather than liberating...

Like Eladine, I gave this high marks, but honestly I much prefer the original, with it's expansive, light, and open feeling.

(5 years and 2711 days ago)

prisoner of the knowledge
avatar Eladine
Eladine says:

its a very powerfull source to use cause it gives an incredible 3d effect that takes a lot of time to make if you had to do it without a source like this.. The trick is to place it where it belongs.. so it feels as if its at home as if it has been created to be at that place.. Thats the feeling that mqtrf had created in his image.. and more..

Your work is very nice too but i think the book the statue is holding is too solid for my idea perhaps u could create a lil more the lines of the pages and put some shades on the pages so u get a lil bit more depth because holding the book in that position makes for sure the pages that are hanging down on the left side of the book, not touch eachother.. There should be a tiny bit of space between the pages.. and i like to see that back Its allready there a little bit but I dont think its strong enough. I also think the book its holding is too white and can have a little of greyness.. . just like i see that at the books that are hanging.

Ofcourse dont get me wrong this is a very strong image and im just picking to make it even better imo. High marks anyway

(5 years and 2711 days ago)

prisoner of the knowledge
avatar orientallad

nice colors, good composition, i believe that the bottom of the boat should not be faded out, it's suppose to end up with sharp line and a simple splash in case it's moving, good luck.

(5 years and 2731 days ago)

the hide out
avatar jordyponce

Pretty surreal..
i like it author, good work!

(5 years and 2732 days ago)

the hide out
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Perspective on the house is off. You can use Edit/transform/distort to correct it. Otherwise it's a good image.

(5 years and 2735 days ago)

the hide out
avatar CorneliaMladenova

The birds are simply stunning

(5 years and 2786 days ago)

good morning, nocturnal..
avatar mounirupa
mounirupa says:

So Nice.. All the Best author

(5 years and 2789 days ago)

good morning, nocturnal..
avatar DanielaOwergoor

So beautiful...

(5 years and 2789 days ago)

good morning, nocturnal..
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 2789 days ago)

good morning, nocturnal..
avatar erathion
erathion says:

beautiful scene and lovely colors...best of luck author

(5 years and 2790 days ago)

good morning, nocturnal..
avatar CorneliaMladenova

This image simply deserves a big WOW!

(5 years and 2794 days ago)

longing
avatar Hayato
Hayato says:

(5 years and 2794 days ago)

longing
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 2795 days ago)

longing
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Love it, great idea to create clock wheels

(5 years and 2801 days ago)

one happy day
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Great job on this using so many elements of the source. Love the human in the fantasy image, and the birds.

(5 years and 2801 days ago)

one happy day
avatar arca
arca says:

I like it .. has a sweetness to it that is very appealing (to me)

(5 years and 2801 days ago)

one happy day
avatar Drivenslush

I like the Disney feel.. great job

(5 years and 2801 days ago)

one happy day
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Extremely minimal use of the contest source.

(5 years and 2802 days ago)

one happy day
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 2802 days ago)

one happy day
avatar niks1351
niks1351 says:

beautiful

(5 years and 2803 days ago)

once upon the time
avatar aheman
aheman says:

the mist show spread sparingly here n there around the castle..

it looks "white" at the lower third portion of the image

the dome-shape building's perspective seems wrong

improve these and be sure get more "wows"

(5 years and 2804 days ago)

once upon the time
avatar Draco
Draco says:

I like the mist

(5 years and 2805 days ago)

once upon the time
avatar sasikanth123

nice......

(5 years and 2805 days ago)

once upon the time
avatar RIPSAW
RIPSAW says:

(5 years and 2805 days ago)

once upon the time
avatar Hayato
Hayato says:

Congratulation, my friend!

(5 years and 2810 days ago)

metro
avatar niks1351
niks1351 says:

Congrats..... its very nice

(5 years and 2810 days ago)

metro
avatar hereisanoop

Congrats on the 3rd place..

(5 years and 2812 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar loopyluv
loopyluv says:

Congrats!!!

(5 years and 2812 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

a lot is going around in this picture! and that is why is so good! Congrats!

(5 years and 2813 days ago)

metro
avatar lordymail
lordymail says:

wow congrats! cool dragon you have there!

(5 years and 2813 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar madamemonty

Congrats, terrific improvements

(5 years and 2813 days ago)

metro
avatar CorneliaMladenova

I meant Congratulations LOL

(5 years and 2813 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar CorneliaMladenova

ongratulations, Dek!

(5 years and 2813 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar langstrum
langstrum says:

Now that your dragon acts in battle, very great. It's quite strange to me that your dragon has no ... hand, because the rest looks like the common dragon, except that part. The flame is too straight, that' why Anoop said you need to work more on it, I guess. Also, since this flame is strong, you should see the light on the wall and the soldier. The background looks great, too, but if the color is opposite to the dragon (such as orange, red, etc) , you'll get a better effect. Best of luck to you

(5 years and 2814 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar hereisanoop

wonderful work... The flames needed a little more work... Still goes my fav

(5 years and 2815 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar dollmommy
dollmommy says:

Do you have a sbs on the things you did to improve this, I do like it better but inquiring minds want to know your secrets.

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

metro
avatar Drivenslush

Harry POTTER!!! hehehe.. (sorry, there's just been a bazillion of commercials on TV with Harry Potter.. LOL) Great JOB!!

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Beautiful dragon, amazing work on the wings

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar arca
arca says:

Great!

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar niks1351
niks1351 says:

amaaaaaaazingggggggg

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar hereisanoop

The dragon is wonderful

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar George55
George55 says:

Beautiful work.... good imagination and creativity.... good luck!

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Might want to add some glow from the flames, otherwise it's a great job!

(5 years and 2816 days ago)

oopzz...
avatar DanielaOwergoor

Very nice! I like it!

(5 years and 2817 days ago)

metro
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

The round shape on the LH side looks tilted downwards to the right. Is it a stationary building (with people on the edges), or is it a flying saucer?

You also have very inconsistent light sources all over the place, with the sky and flying machines illuminated from the opposite side of the saucer, the background city, the ships (which are lit from above), and the skyscraper, which is lit from the RH middle.

The ant-type creatures on the water, as well as the bridge, show no shading at all on the water, and the reds are too warm in tone for the overall blue cast you have given this image.

It's a very interesting concept, but it is very inconsistent in execution and needs a lot of adjustments to be visually believable.

(5 years and 2819 days ago)

metro
avatar Akassa
Akassa says:

You should work a little on the shadows to create a more realistic effect, nice concept.

(5 years and 2819 days ago)

metro
avatar arca
arca says:

Congrats!!! Very well deserved!

(5 years and 2820 days ago)

miss docter smurf