68 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Too much dead space at the top with the fog. At least the water at the bottom offers some ripples and a whirlpool...

(5 years and 2796 days ago)

night fantasy
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Nice work! Just one suggestion: I'd flip one of the moons. (Oh, and make a SBS too...).
On second look, smooth the jagged edges.

(5 years and 2796 days ago)

night fantasy
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Cool guy

(5 years and 2815 days ago)

woooowww
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Beautiful, love the vibrant colors

(5 years and 2815 days ago)

feathersfish
avatar Rod13
Rod13 says:

I give you props for an original idea.

(5 years and 2815 days ago)

feathersfish
avatar Drivenslush

I really like this one, gives me the heebie jeebies, but still.. nice feel

(5 years and 2818 days ago)

guanawhale
avatar arca
arca says:

I would suggest for future work that you spend a bit more time on your masking. It will help refine and enhance your work. It is a pain to get it right but worth the effort.

It all starts there, no matter how good everything else is, if you have left-over pixels, smudgy bits and outlines it can ruin a great image. You idea is very good, your masking needs some more work. To get you going try checking out this tutorial on how to mask trees ... hope it helps http://www.pxleyes.com/tutorial/photoshop/1272/How-To-Mask-A-Tree-In-3-Minutes.html

(5 years and 2821 days ago)

my fairy mind
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Needs a shadow since the light source is behind.

(5 years and 2822 days ago)

guanawhale
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

If you can't find the link you can't use the image.
EDIT: Good, you found the link! Now think about having the edges of the reflection conform to the ripples in the water.

(5 years and 2822 days ago)

woooowww
avatar robvdn
robvdn says:

I like the overall idea even though, looking at the high-res, the blending can be a lot improved. You might take a small (3 pxl) soft blur brush, create a new layer (check the box on top: "sample all layers" and soften the edges. This way your sources will blend better. There's also a hard edge over the bird it self, you can get rid of that with a bigger soft eraser brush set to 20% and go over the edge multiple times. Might sound like a lot of work but it isn't and it will improve your entry lot.

(5 years and 2823 days ago)

woooowww
avatar DanLundberg

Partially submerged is a fun idea. But the non-solid/non-opaque ceiling arch is odd. And the soffit/cove-ceiling thing on the near right side not matched on the left side is weird that might best be solved by eliminating it from either side both near and far.

(5 years and 2823 days ago)

tropical view
avatar enblanco
enblanco says:

Very interesting entry, GL!

(5 years and 2827 days ago)

my fairy mind
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

That mjrananum green girl on the vine swing is becoming her own meme...Interesting image, but the lighting of the shoe (LH top) does not match the tree (RH side), nor the cow (RH top)...It does match the green foliage on top of the tree, which is also reversed, though...
You may want to try adding some highlights with the Dodge tool at low opacity on the RH side, or flip the shoe. If you reverse the tree and the shoe foliage, the image will look more consistent than at present...
Light source direction is an important consideration.

(5 years and 2829 days ago)

my fairy mind
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

It's kind of dark, but the worms are a great touch! Love how you hollowed his face.

(5 years and 2856 days ago)

HELP MEH
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Super cool scary image...gl author

(5 years and 2860 days ago)

HELP MEH
avatar greymval
greymval says:

This is a nice entry! Fixing some minor issues would further improve it:
1. That metal pipe ( whatever is called ) must be cut out with pen tool in order to avoid chunky shape. Afterwards Ctrl click layer go to Select -modify , contract 2 pixels, invert selection and blur it. Same for the lemon slice in foreground.
Maybe overlaying the sky color on it at a lower oppacity would increase the blending.
2. Use blur and slight desaturation for the lemons in the background to create a better sense of depth.

(5 years and 2860 days ago)

martini beach
avatar erathion
erathion says:

interesting refreshing image...nice colors and some cool effects...GL author

(5 years and 2862 days ago)

martini beach
no avatar
scorpas says:

biggest minus - shadowed lemon... there should be a lighting on the lemon, not a shadow...

(5 years and 2863 days ago)

martini beach
no avatar
jacktired says:

the color of the liquid in the glass doesn't show any of the blue behind it. The extra lemon slices look shadowed. The ice blue ice cubes in the water are the wrong blue. The glass doesn't sit in the water deep enough, it looks like it's on top of the water.

(5 years and 2864 days ago)

martini beach
avatar DanLundberg

Refreshing, but that's not a martini glass and why is the foreground lemon shadowed instead of casting a shadow?

(5 years and 2864 days ago)

martini beach
avatar DanLundberg

Lots of cool stuff, but some problems as well: The space-suit guys are WAY too big. The stars wouldn't shine through the moon, neither the lit nor dark portions.

(5 years and 2866 days ago)

code red
avatar pixelkid
pixelkid says:

If you could somehow make all the parts share the same light source...that would be really cool. The people need to have their left sides light and right sides darker. This is very surreal and cool...and with the suggestion I've made it might help it be even better. Just a thought. Nice job, author! I like your thinking.

(5 years and 2874 days ago)

the last giants discover
avatar bcabilan
bcabilan says:

These might be the goddesses of stone? lol! Gud luck author.

(5 years and 2917 days ago)

stone camoflash woman
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Needs a reflection.

(5 years and 2942 days ago)

dream bed
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Obvious distortion of the woman, otherwise just clean up a few edges & it's an interesting entry.

(5 years and 2942 days ago)

for ever waiting
avatar SekiHara
SekiHara says:

the idea is cool, but the woman is flat and I would like to see SBS.

=)

(5 years and 2943 days ago)

for ever waiting
avatar dannifood4less

looks like this was done in M$ paint. Text looks very plain, unbelievable, and the image is very grainy. Not to mention Osama is believed to be dead.

(5 years and 2943 days ago)

the new 11-11-11 plan reveal
avatar erathion
erathion says:

cool work author...love the approach...small nit pick...skin color on his hand is way different of his face color...but maybe that is ok cause in terrorist camps his face is always exposed to the sun, but his hands are always in the pockets...

(5 years and 2944 days ago)

the new 11-11-11 plan reveal
avatar erathion
erathion says:

cool work...gl

(5 years and 2944 days ago)

dream bed
avatar CMYK46
CMYK46 says:

Good idea, but Bin Laden's head is distorted, and I doubt we'd ever see him in a suit & tie! GL author.

(5 years and 2945 days ago)

the new 11-11-11 plan reveal
avatar rbsgrl
rbsgrl says:

Oh my...very imaginative!! I like that you chose Time for your magazine!

(5 years and 2945 days ago)

the new 11-11-11 plan reveal
avatar jcfreak6363

Bin Laden's head/face needs to be blurred a bit. Maybe a little noise and slight desaturation too. I like the idea although it's kinda scary. GL author.

(5 years and 2945 days ago)

the new 11-11-11 plan reveal
avatar arca
arca says:

Interesting!

(5 years and 2954 days ago)

Re-construct
avatar George55
George55 says:

Good aproach to the real Michael. Good luck.

(5 years and 2955 days ago)

the legend m.j.
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

(5 years and 2956 days ago)

the legend m.j.
avatar erathion
erathion says:

nice work...gl

(5 years and 2956 days ago)

Re-construct
avatar erathion
erathion says:

cool interpretation author...good luck

(5 years and 2957 days ago)

the legend m.j.
avatar CrystleClear

lol..i like this a lot..maybe the eye lashes need to be longer and dont forget the heavy eyeliner -then it will definitely resemble michael. GREAT JOB!

(5 years and 2958 days ago)

the legend m.j.
avatar greymval
greymval says:

I'm glad that people like it, I don't No offence man, but there's just too much going on.
I get the skull breaking through her head skin, and the blood and the flames. But why do you need cigare smoke over the fire and 2 of the same rose on top?

(5 years and 3062 days ago)

death rose face
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Disturbing, but very creative! The jaw is too warped and the LH side of the "flames" is a bit too high contrast, fighting the image for dominance, but the overall concept is wonderful.

(5 years and 3063 days ago)

death rose face
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

BTW, welcome to PXL!

(5 years and 3063 days ago)

death rose face
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

I LOVE IT!!!!! and I'm happy to give it my highest approving comment:


---WICKED-COOL!!!---


Not that you need it much but GL!

(5 years and 3063 days ago)

death rose face
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Great effects author and very nice work...gl

(5 years and 3089 days ago)

cristal cat
no avatar
marina08 says:

It's so weird! But I like it!

(5 years and 3090 days ago)

cristal cat
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

In a good way of course.

(5 years and 3091 days ago)

cristal cat
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

Those eyes are piercing!

(5 years and 3091 days ago)

cristal cat
avatar arca
arca says:

Very interesting composition ... the outline around her could be softened a bit ... it is a little rough in Hi res (using the blur tool on a very low setting can help eliminate this and/or a low setting clone over the outline helps too).

Edit: Clever solution to the issue

(5 years and 3104 days ago)

extravaganca
avatar MnMCarta
MnMCarta says:

I can see this in the game of Final Fantasy!

(5 years and 3112 days ago)

queen of the night
avatar arca
arca says:

Fascinating image ... the concept is lovely. In hi-res I noticed it could use a little clean up on the chop of the woman. A little smoother cut around the hand and removing the stray pixels would help.

Lovely image though!

(5 years and 3115 days ago)

queen of the night
avatar MossyB
MossyB says:

Too blurry, rather than smoky/misty/ethereal. The stars also look a little flat and fakey.

(5 years and 3115 days ago)

queen of the night