3625 comments received ( finished contests only ):
avatar gamemastertips

Beautiful image...a great surrealistic effect. Would be cleaner if there was perhaps a little more grass emerging from the front of the tree rather than just out to the sides. Otherwise this is probably my favourite entry here, so far. Nice work an good luck!

(5 years and 3153 days ago)

New Life
avatar dekwid
dekwid says:

very nice,....something mystical on ti,......

(5 years and 3153 days ago)

New Life
avatar nasirkhan
nasirkhan says:

Nice work author. Agree with langstrum. I also suggest to replace cloud/sky with some other stock. It looks white in the center. Also slightly reduce vintage. Good luck

EDIT: Great change . Now cloud and whole composition is much better.

(5 years and 3153 days ago)

New Life
avatar langstrum
langstrum says:

Very good. The only thing I would change if I were you is the composition, I prefer the tree in the lower position, leaving some air on top of the tree. This image reminds me Ponti55

(5 years and 3153 days ago)

New Life
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Great work author,as guys before sad i love colors very much,but best in this creation is that overall mystic look...well done

(5 years and 3154 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar skeletor
skeletor says:

very nice scene!

(5 years and 3155 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Very creative, different approach. Nice job, author.

(5 years and 3156 days ago)

Boundless
avatar genuine2009

nice colours......

(5 years and 3156 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar jawshoewhah
jawshoewhah [banned] says:

nice originality. GL!

(5 years and 3156 days ago)

Boundless
avatar dekwid
dekwid says:

I am not the type of TALK MORE DO LESS man,...so I just say this is nice, just like nasir said....and I agree with erikuri too

(5 years and 3156 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar nasirkhan
nasirkhan says:

Nice composition and great color

(5 years and 3156 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar RickyRuckus

i am a fan of this work!

(5 years and 3157 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Nice compo, I like the colors... I still can't get this result on my works, the mood is incredible!

(5 years and 3157 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar neeraj55
neeraj55 says:

good luck author !

(5 years and 3157 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar ramsesje
ramsesje says:

how com you see so many pictures on your sceenshot. I only get 32 pictures on one page in flickr

(5 years and 3157 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar Clinge
Clinge says:

Beautifull mood and image, GL

(5 years and 3158 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
no avatar
Widiar says:

I would do bit more work with the foreground tower blending, it looks like it's sunk to the ground and also the perspective with the tree is a bit weird. It looks like the base is in behind the tree or at the same depth, but the upper part is in front.

Overall it IS a bit surrealistic, so I'm ok with the title. Good colours and mood, worth tweaking a bit more.

(5 years and 3158 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar DanLundberg

Nice moody feel and pleasant enough, but I don't know what I should be focusing on. Also, the landscape seems pretty realistic to me (aside from the miniature foreground tower [or giant background pagoda]), so I don't get the reference to 'surrealism' in your title.

(5 years and 3158 days ago)

Hybrid Surrealism
avatar demi
demi says:

very good work,good luck

(5 years and 3161 days ago)

Boundless
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

And congrats again for another great third place!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar Lelaina
Lelaina says:

Congrats for your third place, Tucker! This was for sure the best of all three versions!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Constructed
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

Congrats on your 3rd place, dude!!!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Constructed
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Very cool work author,great surreal composition...just and idea,how about adding some bird,flying up from don't used fingers...best of luck

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Boundless
avatar nasirkhan
nasirkhan says:

Congrats!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar nasirkhan
nasirkhan says:

Congrats! for 3rd place

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Constructed
avatar Christy
Christy says:

Love the idea!! My only suggestion is that the shadows and the lighting aren't matching...Like the shadow on the gazelle's legs are really strong but the hand is bright like the sun was facing it...If this was your intention it's right on and best of luck

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Boundless
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Nice surrealism!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Boundless
avatar Drivenslush

what a great idea.. GOOD LUCK!!!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Boundless
avatar dekwid
dekwid says:

congrats for the 3nd

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

Congrats for 3rd

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar RichieMB
RichieMB says:

Congrats for 3rd

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Constructed
avatar Warlock
Warlock [banned] says:

Congrats again good week for you!!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar Warlock
Warlock [banned] says:

Congrats superb work!

(5 years and 3162 days ago)

Constructed
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

good idea, and nice work, author, love it! on theme to me, too.

(5 years and 3163 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar nasirkhan
nasirkhan says:

Very nice work author

(5 years and 3163 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar RickLaMesa

nice job

(5 years and 3163 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar CorneliaMladenova

Nicely done!

(5 years and 3163 days ago)

Constructed
avatar pearlie
pearlie says:

nice work here!

(5 years and 3164 days ago)

Constructed
avatar spaceranger

I agree with Warlock in all respects!

(5 years and 3164 days ago)

Constructed
avatar Warlock
Warlock [banned] says:

Hair line is much improved, a far more convicting natural result....top job! and good luck

(5 years and 3164 days ago)

Constructed
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

I think the eyes are a little small, but the whole image is very well done. GL, author!

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Constructed
avatar spaceranger

Very nicely done, strong colors. I agree with Warlock about the hairline and the nose. Try using the smudge tool at a fairly low setting and a small brush and pull away from the hair edge into the skin to simulate the hairs at the hairline edge. The nose is just a bit of a tweak to fix. (Did I just tell you to tweak your nose?) None the less a good entry!

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Constructed
avatar Warlock
Warlock [banned] says:

Very impressive dude! Looks a little mean and moody, nice use of D.O.F. my only suggestions would be the hair line, need to get a small fine brush in there and add the hair in stead if it just fading away, and the columella is a little to pinched.

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Constructed
avatar erathion
erathion says:

Nice construction author...good luck

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Constructed
avatar serialkiller

fantastic work, author! love it! good luck!

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar lchappell
lchappell says:

"Or will the attack come from machines we would never even have suspected?" "Be creative and good luck!" Fits the bill to me.

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar DanLundberg

Very appealing image, but I don't see the 'revenge' part (critical to the 'nightmarish' requirement of the contest). [Maybe noxious CO2 emissions out the tail pipes? ]

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar erikuri
erikuri says:

Imagine all those cars flying over our heads!...
Pretty cool, GL!

(5 years and 3165 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar erathion
erathion says:

very is damn Harry Potter...,,,great work author

(5 years and 3166 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers
avatar blackxhijd

awsome

(5 years and 3166 days ago)

Revenge of the Clunkers