Photoshopper Comments placed and received

I like your idea and work here.
The end result looks good.

I have my doubts about the vignetting, for me this doesnt add to the image. It gives me the feeling that the animal is beeing squished, instead of making it stand out. But that is a personal prefference.

Looks so much better now. Great work on giving the water the proper reflections of colors and object aswell.
Now the image truely is one piece.

Great work and good luck.

I like the overall look, but IMHO it needs some work.

We can see through the tree. For example the bottom part of the tree, we can see the ground through it.
The edge of the water needs some work aswell. On the left for example you have a "straight cut line".

Good luck.

This is so "cool".

Congrats!

Looks so nice ! ( but beeing honest, i like the trees in the background most :O )

WTF! was my first reaction...., but in a good way. It made me laugh alot.

So thanks for the laugh.

Good job and good luck.

Awesome

I like this !

Nice

Creative, first sight i could easely see its a fish. Second i went reading what it said, could read it. So thats all positive points.

Good job, and good luck.

The rope is forming the letters R o p e.

Instead the contest goal was to have the letters of a word ( for example ROPE ) form the object, in this case a rope.

So "R O P E" should be used to form a rope.

Even tho i realy like the image, and you done a good job.
I have to say this.

The goal is to have the letters of a word form the object of that word.
You have used people to for the word people.
Wich means, you used an object ( people )( sorry for that comparisson ) to form the word.

Sorry to notify.

Good thinking, nice result.

Good luck.

I lolled

This "prototype" is looking better and better xD.

I recommend not taking a shortcut!

Can i please have my shoes back?

Good job !

Very funny!

Changing the light on the hand, would make it perfect.

Edit: No not too bright. The colors are fine. Just the hand is missing out the light wich is casted on everything else.