Onager Comments placed and received

we all feel better in the dark!

the highlight would be more convincing if you could put a light source coming from the inside.

lanterns are made of a sheer paper, you should remove the highlight from the top and add a "hot" spot where the light from the inside is showing thru, like a thin lamp shade at night! more like this image: http://www.worldofstock.com/closeups/TAE2373.php

lights should be from inside

wonderful cartoon recreation good luck author.

Good Luck

very nice

good

good work, but difference in style(some places bewel effect used) create issues.

very cool

very nice idea good luck!

I like the colors. A silhouette of a destroyed sity in the background would add to the feel I think you're going for. I like this one.

I think you did a great job enhancing the original!! IMO the purple hair just doesn't seem to fit the rest of the image...Good Luck

its a dolphin... its a walrus... its... a girl?? i like it

Love the mood. Very good. Good luck

I lile the photoshop work but the composition is a little weak. Maybe would work better in a horizontal composition with less negative space and more air in front of the figure. IMHO.

become little flat, give dimension

The light source on the rocks is from the left, but the main area is effective enough that it's not real noticeable.

Very nice. I noticed just a tiny tiny bit of white around her hand. Other than that, it's perfect as is.

great idea to make the lace as a bronze statue to the contest of lace