Nice work but the bottom of the tree (Stones) were cut wrongly, a part of the sea can be seen from the stones, try to fix it and give the stones some sand effect to be more realistic otherwise it's a good picture.

Nice idea -- the rope is not correctly shaped -- if it is meant to be pulled tight then it would not have the loop shape at the tree but be elongated or the loop would be tight on the tree -- if the rope is slack the loop would still drape the tree or be on the ground and the rope would have a curved shape.

em agree with you Alan, rope must be curved shape and the position of rope should be bottom!

needs a lot of work but the idea is kind of good...
please edit and upload it again
till then i am holding on to my vote