Very well done image!

wow i thought it was real for a moment!! amazing job

Great job on the water GL

Thank you for comments.

Whoa! nice one. I'm totally a cat person. One thing though, the cat seems a bit pasted, add some tones. Above all a great entry with wonderful execution. Good luck author

great job with the underwtare and water part...i'm not that sertain about the cat and shadow, but it might be my opinion only...good luck

Fantastic!, great imagination and very well done but....the cat is not very well. Anyway great job.

Thanks again for your comments.

@Author A few things:
The cat's posture is a bit weird w.r.t. the contour of the chimney. Some puppet warp might help to align that front paw resting "mid-air". The tones are tad warm & saturated a bit more that the environment. Shadows are present but the whole body of the cat is equally lit. Try burning some of that or painting with a soft brush.

I liked this work, including the idea.
I liked what I did with the water.
But at the same points I agree with nbaztec.
Good luck author.

Moved the cat to the right. Worked on shadow and gave some tones to the fur of the cat using the burn and dodge tools.

Good job on the cat's new position & tones. Try playing around with HSB and/or Levels to get to that Goldilocks point. The image is very well done by the way. Good luck once again author.

I lowered the saturation on the water, to make it look better. Thanks for suggestions.

Great mood, the cat is so sweet

It's really good, I liked this work.
I just choose another starry sky to be more natural because this is not very convincing, IMO ..

I changed the stars DanielaOwergoor, to make it look more realistic. Thanks for the advice.

Very realistic and very good idea!!
Good job author!!

I agree with Daniela, the stars look giant, from a roof you cannot see such big dots on the sky. Anyway it's a very good change, good work author.

Lighting seems unpersuasive to me a little. Nice chop otherwise. Good luck author.

Nice scene, proportions are believable. I do think however , the foreground should be darker and the contrast on the rooftop should be reduced. Apart from that its a nice job.

I like the composition. Maybe you could add some grain to the background image to balance it with the foreground.

Thx dustfinger, but i don't think i'll have the time for that ;-(

Beautiful landscape. Good luck author

thanks! nbaztec like it!

NIce and clean....good luck.

thanks! freejay.........

I loved it.
Very well done, "clean" as freejay said, very realistic and well equalized.
Good luck, author!

thanks! DanielaOwergoor....................

Good job. Repeating the chimney is a nice detail.